Ritodhi C.
Yelp
A casual counterpart to the elegant Da Marco, Vinoteca Poscole is named for a major thoroughfare in Udine, Italy, hometown of its founding chef, Marco Wiles. The emphasis here is on Old World wines, Italian small plates such as salumi and bruschette, and home-style pizzas and pastas. The environment takes the form of a dim but lively cottage, complete with a fireplace and wooden tables that are close enough to feel intimate but far enough to afford privacy. Everything is affordable, and it will be tough to leave anything but full.
Carrots - aggressively charred batons, whose caramelized bitterness is soothed by a refreshing mix of olive oil, parsley, pistachios, and tangy yogurt
Fritto - I found the Suppli (fried risotto balls) to be on the bland side, though texturally pleasant. The pumpkin and goat cheese crocchette were better: savory with a sharp, maple-y sweetness to the molten filling.
Eggplant "La Parmigiana" - a simple dish with components that were good individually, but didn't necessarily come together into a greater whole. The gooey mozzarella-parmesan topping was yummy, and the well-rounded tomato sauce and breaded eggplant were solid, but there was something missing to smooth the edges. Maybe fresh basil?
Crispy Calamari and Shrimp - not your typical heavily breaded sea critters served with marinara and lemon. This was a phenomenal zesty preparation of lightly battered and deftly seasoned seafood nestled among garlicky potatoes, sour capers, and acidic red onions. One of my favorites.
Pappardelle with Pheasant and Mushrooms - long bouncy pasta in a deeply rustic sauce that sticks lovingly to each ribbon. Garlicky and earthy with an oily sheen.
Maccheroni - bite-sized miniature pasta in a creamy sauce of prosciutto, peas, and scallions. Salty, decadent, and palate pleasing.
Butternut Squash Risotto - this one was rich and heavy, but a tad sweet for my taste. Seasoned well, but I felt it could use more funkiness and perhaps the addition of an herb such as sage to brighten it up.
La Dolce Vita - I used to love the original Dolce Vita before it closed, and unfortunately this pizza with taleggio cheese, pear, and copious amounts of arugula did not live up to the name. The thin crust was not crisp, there was barely any cheese, and the entire thing was cold. The worst item on the table.
Chocolate Budino - solid but not amazing. More cake than pudding, which was unexpected. Was hoping for a denser, less airy mouthfeel with more sweet richness. The cookie crumble was necessary for crunch.
Mille Fogle - a crunchy pastry lined with fluffy sweet cream and strawberries. A relatively light and interesting finish to the evening.
I think the 4.5/5 rating that Vinoteca Poscol currently holds is just right. The pastas in particular and some of the smaller plates were fantastic, the desserts were slightly above average, but the pizza was a let-down. This is one of the best date night haunts in town, and writing this account made me crave another round.