Cheesy Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Upper West Side

"The name says it all at this Upper West Side institution dedicated to the dairy component of the classic slice. The cheese here is so profuse, it threatens to roll off the pie. Sure, the crust is a bit doughy and pale ensuring the sauce recedes into the background. But gradually as you eat it, you’ll realize the other components have been formulated so you can better worship the molten cheese." - Robert Sietsema

NYC’s Top Pizza Slices, Mapped - Eater NY

Robert Sietsema

2640 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 Get directions

ordercheesypizzamenu.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Thanh Đa

Vietnamese restaurant · Sunset Park

At this cozy, no-frills Vietnamese spot in Sunset Park, you can savor the city's best banh mi and comforting bowls of pho, all crafted with fresh ingredients and bustling takeout vibes.

7 Postcards

Rai Rai Ken Harlem

Ramen restaurant · Hamilton Heights

This cozy East Village noodle bar serves up satisfying ramen, dumplings, and steamed buns, making it a go-to for quick, delicious comfort food.

2 Postcards

Rodo Foods

West African restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant

Rodo Foods is a cozy Bed-Stuy gem serving mouthwatering West African comfort food, with standout suya and jollof rice that'll keep you coming back.

1 Postcard

Tender Greens - CLOSED

American restaurant · Gramercy

Branch of an LA-based chain for salads, sandwiches & build-your-own plates with local ingredients.

6 Postcards

Via Carota

Italian restaurant · West Village

Via Carota is a buzzing Italian trattoria in the West Village, celebrated for its rustic charm, exceptional handmade pastas, and vibrant seasonal dishes that make every visit feel like a special occasion.

95 Postcards

I Sodi

Tuscan restaurant · West Village

I Sodi, the charming Tuscan hideaway in the West Village, serves up celebrated, many-layered lasagna alongside impeccable pastas and inviting negronis in a cozy, rustic setting.

48 Postcards

Superiority Burger

Restaurant · East Village

Nestled in a retro diner vibe, Superiority Burger serves up innovative vegetarian fare like a beloved quinoa-cheekpea burger and a dreamy collard greens sandwich, with desserts that are simply unmissable—plus a solid lineup of cocktails for good measure.

104 Postcards

Contra

New American restaurant · Lower East Side

This chic New American spot serves up a creative fixed-price dinner menu that's fresh, inventive, and delightfully unpretentious, perfect for a memorable night out.