Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Pie shop · Red Hook

11

@eater

Where to Get Thanksgiving Pies in NYC | Eater NY

"The key lime pie is a very particular type of pie, and purists know the difference between bakers that use fresh ingredients and those that take shortcuts. Discerning fans in search of the real deal will need to head to Red Hook. One of the few shops that use freshly squeezed key limes year-round, there are no slices offered here, just whole pies, but a four-inch mini version will happily feed one. Or try the shop’s popular Swingles: a mini key lime pie stuck on a stick, dipped in chocolate, and frozen –- also in chocolate raspberry and chocolate chipotle flavors. Pies run from $25 for eight-inch (serves four) and $35 for 10-inch (serves eight) with delivery as an option; pickup is the way to go." - Eater Staff

https://ny.eater.com/maps/best-pie-nyc
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

keylime.com
@stevesauthentic

11 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

82 Stanton

Bar · Lower East Side

Happy hour specials & diverse drink menu; great staff

2 Postcards

Milk Bar

Dessert shop · Nolita

Inventive desserts like Cereal Milk soft serve, Compost Cookie

5 Postcards

Kogane

Ramen restaurant · Brooklyn Heights

Hearty ramen & Japanese sides in a warm, snug wood-walled space

2 Postcards

STK Steakhouse Downtown NYC

Steak house · West Village

Steakhouse with rooftop & DJ, known for perfectly cooked cuts

4 Postcards

Döner Haus

Halal restaurant · Bayside

German Döner Kebabs, Zabiha halal, stuffed with meat, veggies, garlic sauce

1 Postcard

SingleCut Beersmiths QNS

Brewery · Astoria

Brewery with IPAs, stouts, live music, pinball & vinyl

7 Postcards

Comfortland

American restaurant · Lower East Side

Nashville hot chicken, empanadas, BBQ Crunchwrap

3 Postcards

Wildair

New American restaurant · Lower East Side

Creative American small plates & natural wines, standout desserts

59 Postcards

The Coffee Shop

Brazilian restaurant · Chelsea

Brazilian-American eats, late-night scene, sidewalk seats

1 Postcard

Sunday In Brooklyn

American restaurant · Williamsburg

Iconic malted pancakes with hazelnut maple praline

33 Postcards