5
"A restaurant that opened the past summer on Shelter Island; the author had been a few times and was looking forward to returning for a birthday dinner but had to cancel due to illness." - Alan Sytsma, Adam Mazur
Hearth-driven French-Italian fare with local ingredients
29 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 Get directions
$100+
Chinese restaurant · Shelter Island
Asian fare, dumplings, crepes, and 2 dozen gelato flavors
3 Postcards
Bar & grill · Shelter Island
Creative eats, cocktails, waterfront views, and a boat dock
1 Postcard
Bed & breakfast · Shelter Island
Victorian inn with guestrooms, cottage, and salon
0 Postcards
Restaurant · Shelter Island
Local produce, seafood & wine at a quaint cottage spot
Nature preserve · Shelter Island
Coastal nature reserve with diverse landscapes, wildlife and trails
Hamburger restaurant · Midtown West
Classic smashburgers, Impossible burgers, and crispy fries
25 Postcards
Caterer · Greenpoint
Full-service caterer focusing on local, sustainable menu items
15 Postcards
Pizza restaurant · East Village
Authentic NY-style pizza, hand-tossed slices, cozy booths
4 Postcards
Fine dining restaurant · Brooklyn Heights
Michelin-starred tasting menu with seafood focus
35 Postcards
Hot pot restaurant · East Village
Individual Sichuan hot pot bowls, customizable with fresh ingredients