"Lucrezia stands on the northern edge of a village, its soft-pink walls embracing it protectively. There’s no inkling of what to expect within, but soon you spot a door cut into an old wooden gate and seconds later you’re stepping through into another world, swapping the dust of the village for a wonderful courtyard garden. You’re entranced immediately - the colour, the style, the sense of peace, all fill you with instant pleasure. It’s a lovely surprise - you probably didn’t expect to find this measure of beauty within. But now it’s yours and soon you’re sitting under a tree with a glass of something cool to welcome you into the fold. This 17th-century house belonged to owner David’s grandfather, a gathering place for several generations of the extended family. When he died no one could bear to part with it, so they decided to turn it into a lovely small hotel, keeping the feel of the past alive while adding the comforts of the present. It’s gorgeous from top to toe - 8 smart rooms, generous prices, lovely staff on-hand to help - but it’s the garden that steals the show, a lushly shaded wonderland with tables and chairs scattered about in all the right places, and a massage tent in a quiet corner. Add a string of beaches to the east and the coastal ruins of Phoenician Tharros and you’ll find this small slice of heaven hard to leave. One of the loveliest hotels on the island, simple as that. Highs There are 20 beaches within 20km - sunset is usually rather good - and beautiful bird-filled lagoons behind them, where pink flamingos gather in April The courtyard garden (where meals are also served) - you’ll be coming back from the beach earlier than you think The sense of staying at a proper old country house - there's a billiards room and free house aperitifs are served at sunset Phoenician Tharros, its beautiful ruins slipping gracefully into the sea nearby You’re well positioned to explore the island - the fast road makes day trips easy Lows The village (Riola Sardo) is a bit dull, but once ensconced in the courtyard, you forget it’s there There’s no pool, but you do have 20 beaches within easy striking distance Some may find the decor a little too old-fashioned but we loved it" - Tom Bell