The Best Pizza In New Haven, Connecticut 2024
"There are Pepe’s people, and there are Sally’s people, and what Sally’s does best is the Potato & Rosemary Special: the potatoes are paper thin, barely weighing the slices down, and the rosemary will instantly remind you of Thanksgiving dinner. But you really can’t go wrong with any of the pies—each has just the right amount of sauce and toppings to let the quality of the crust shine through. Out of all the New Haven spots, Sally’s has gone the most corporate and has expanded to new locations that all feel a bit soulless. This original New Haven location is the one you want to go to—their dining room has that classic apizza joint charm, with cushy leather booths, vintage light fixtures, and old photos and posters lining their wood-paneled walls." - ciera velarde, holland white
