"The most intriguing cookie in our tasting—with strips of nori ribboning through the milk and dark chocolate—and the most divisive. The umami-sweet aftertaste and caramelized sugar bitterness aren’t for everyone, but if you like unusual pairings, definitely check out Elbow’s cookie for yourself. In terms of thickness and size, it hits a perfect middle mark, and there’s some great crisp-to-soft action as you move from the sides to the center." - molly fitzpatrick, bryan kim, willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah