Gage & Tollner

American restaurant · Downtown Brooklyn

59

@infatuation

The 15 Best Steakhouses In NYC

"Gage & Tollner is a storied Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse... sort of. It opened in 1892, closed in 2004, briefly housed a TGI Fridays, and then reopened under new ownership in 2021. If you're looking for a classic, old-school steakhouse where the wedge salad most definitely has iceberg lettuce, this might not be the steakhouse for you. But for perfect martinis, an overflowing raw bar, and a Brooklyn-based indie artist in the booth behind you, Gage & Tollner is a great choice. Think of it as the steakhouse for farmers market enthusiasts. Come for a special occasion, always get with the signature baked alaska, and consider a drink at their upstairs tiki bar after dinner." - neha talreja, kenny yang, carina finn koeppicus, bryan kim, willa moore

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/best-steakhouses-nyc

372 Fulton St 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

gageandtollner.com
@gage.and.tollner

59 Postcards

Reserve
See full details

More Places For You

The Tusk Bar

Cocktail bar · Midtown East

Tusk Bar at the Evelyn Hotel is an upscale spot that serves delightful seafood bites and inventive cocktails, all wrapped in a cozy, jazzy atmosphere.

9 Postcards

Veselka

Ukrainian restaurant · East Village

Veselka is a bustling East Village icon serving comforting Ukrainian pierogi, borscht, and homestyle fare in a lively, retro diner setting.

71 Postcards

456 New Shanghai

Shanghainese restaurant · Chinatown

Step into 456 Shanghai, a reimagined Chinatown gem cranking out expertly crafted soup dumplings and Shanghainese classics in a cozy spot on Mott Street.

3 Postcards

Pio Pio 6

Peruvian restaurant · Upper West Side

Pio Pio is a vibrant Peruvian spot where juicy rotisserie chicken meets hearty sides, all enjoyed in a lively, family-friendly atmosphere.

1 Postcard

169 Bar

Bar · Lower East Side

Divey LES bar decked out with palm trees, a leopard-print pool table, lively vibes, cheap drinks, tasty dumplings, and a dash of kitschy charm.

9 Postcards

LOS TACOS No.1

Taco restaurant · Chelsea

Los Tacos No. 1 is a lively taco haven near Penn Station, dishing out mouthwatering tacos and quesadillas with no sit-down fuss—just grab and savor!

7 Postcards

Ceres

Pizza restaurant · Little Italy

Crafted by Eleven Madison Park alums, Ceres serves up super thin, crispy New York–style sourdough pizza with inventive toppings in a cozy, wood-paneled spot.

2 Postcards

Bobbi’s Italian beef

Sandwich shop · Carroll Gardens

Bobbi’s Italian Beef brings a slice of Chicago to Cobble Hill, serving up juicy, savory Italian beef sandwiches, authentic Chicago dogs, and classic tavern-style pizza in a quirky retro space that transports diners back to the '80s.

13 Postcards

Rosticceria Evelina

Italian restaurant · Clinton Hill

Rosticceria Evelina serves standout rotisserie chicken, wood-fired pizzas, and hearty pastas in a bright spot with a charming covered garden.

5 Postcards

The Long Island Bar

Cocktail bar · Cobble Hill

Long Island Bar in Cobble Hill serves classic cocktails and juicy double-patty burgers in a retro diner setting with old-school neon vibes.

21 Postcards