Toasties E. 51st

Deli · Midtown East

1

@infatuation

"Crying people need food too - and that’s where Toasties comes in. The next time you plan on crawling underneath your desk and having a good cry, get a sandwich here first. We suggest the “Sloop Dan B.” It has turkey, pastrami, Monterey jack, cole slaw, and Russian dressing. And if that doesn’t do it for you, there are a bunch of other hot and cold options (and they also do salads). When you need to fill a void in your life with bread and cheese, and you just don’t care how you get it, Toasties is there for you. We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Team Infatuation

Toasties - Review - New York - The Infatuation
Infatuation - Reviews

23 E 51st St, New York, NY 10022, USA Get directions

toastiesnyc.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Caracas Arepa Bar

Bar · East Village

Arepa aficionados seek out the Venezuelan bites at this take-out arm of the nearby sit-down space.

5 Postcards

Massara

Italian restaurant · Flatiron District

Massara, a vibrant new Italian eatery in Flatiron, serves up coastal Southern Italian delights with house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzettes, and standout dishes like candele and chilled spaghetti, all housed in a chic two-story space that captures the warmth of Campania.

13 Postcards

Burger By Day

Hamburger restaurant · Lower East Side

Nestled in Chinatown, Burger By Day serves standout smashburgers and chicken sandwiches in a relaxed vibe, perfect for a satisfying, casual meal.

4 Postcards

Rosticceria Evelina

Italian restaurant · Clinton Hill

Rosticceria Evelina in Clinton Hill serves up mouthwatering rotisserie chicken, delicious pizzas, and pasta-style dishes in a bright, inviting space.

5 Postcards

Red Coffee Stand

Coffee shop · DUMBO

Tucked away in DUMBO, Red Coffee Stand serves up bold coffee and cozy soups, making it your go-to spot for warmth on chilly days.

1 Postcard

Hindu Temple Canteen

South Indian restaurant · Flushing

Tucked away in the basement of Flushing's oldest Hindu temple, the Ganesh Temple Canteen serves up delicious, budget-friendly South Indian vegetarian fare, with crispy dosas and family-style seating making it a local favorite.

8 Postcards

John's of Bleecker Street

Pizza restaurant · West Village

At this historic West Village pizzeria, founded in 1929, you’ll find expertly-charred coal-oven pies that are crisp, thin, and utterly satisfying—no slices, just the whole delicious experience.

18 Postcards

Ro's Diner

Vegan restaurant · Williamsburg

Ro's Diner in Williamsburg serves up comforting, all-vegan diner fare like pancakes and cheesesteaks in a retro, lively atmosphere perfect for hangovers.

6 Postcards

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

Barbecue restaurant · Morningside Heights

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que offers a lively Southern-style dining experience with succulent smoked meats, cold beers, and a retro vibe, perfect for family gatherings or casual meet-ups.

14 Postcards

P.J. Clarke's

American restaurant · Upper West Side

P.J. Clarke's is a historic tavern just steps from Lincoln Center, serving up mouthwatering burgers and American classics in a lively, retro-chic setting.

6 Postcards