"The Deal: $45 Lunch, $45 Dinner There are two distinct types of Coney Island days to have. You can sit on the beach, ride The Cyclone, and eat some very famous hot dogs, or you can button yourself up and watch as waiters in red tuxedos deliver you pasta at Gargiulo’s. We always go for the baked clams and calamari racanati when we come here. Just make sure you aren’t wearing flip-flops—Gargiulo’s has a dress code. " - bryan kim, willa moore, sonal shah, neha talreja, will hartman, molly fitzpatrick