Best Burgers in Indianapolis (2025)

A 1918 Westside institution where the double cheeseburger is smashed wafer-thin on a steel flat top, served Big Mac–style with a middle slice of bread. Lauded by Food & Wine and spotlighted by local TV, it remains cash-only and 21+.

This Meridian-Kessler classic is beloved for its griddled cheeseburger, jukebox of Big Band 45s, and steadfast house rules. Celebrated by Indianapolis Monthly and even noted in The New York Times’ travel coverage, it’s pure Indy character on a bun.

A neighborhood beer bar that treats burgers with the same care as its 38 taps, from a juicy Fischer Farms beef patty to a cult-favorite black bean or turkey burger. Praised by local food writers for balanced builds and dialed-in sides.

Broad Ripple’s one-stop for thick, juicy Black Angus patties on sturdy potato rolls, plus a connected Indiana-focused taproom. Frequently cited by Indianapolis Monthly for its namesake burger and smart toppings, it’s a reliable neighborhood favorite.

A lively, retro-styled diner where the smashburger shines—customizable or as the house Strut with smoked gouda, mango chutney, and dazzle sauce. Covered by local outlets and running a current 2025 menu, it pairs burgers with boozy shakes and a big patio.

Irvington’s indie smash shop sells out for a reason: crisp-edged patties, playful builds like the Sleepy Hollow, and local beer. Covered by Axios Indianapolis at opening and still humming, it’s a neighborhood favorite with patio hangs and Dole Whip.

An Eastside landmark since 1960, featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. Order the Twin Steer double-decker with house sauce, then finish with cream pie—classic Hoosier diner fare that still draws locals morning to night.

A vintage drive-in just west of downtown, pouring homemade root beer and griddling burgers the same way for decades. Still locally run and operating with carhop service, it’s peak race-week nostalgia with the double cheeseburger and onion rings.

Indy’s first all-plant-based burger joint turns out craveable doubles, loaded fries, and weekend brunch specials. Featured on Eater’s 2025 citywide best list, it proves a meatless burger can satisfy hard-core burger fans, too.

Canal-side hangout with a quietly excellent burger—juicy, straightforward, and best enjoyed on the deck. It’s long been a Broad Ripple standby and earns nods from local guides for relaxed vibes, live music, and solid pub fare.