3

Mama Santa's

Italian restaurant · Little Italy ·

Mama Santa's

Italian restaurant · Little Italy ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Little Italy’s longtime standard‑bearer (family‑run since 1961) turns out crisp, thin pies alongside old‑school red‑sauce hits. It’s as much a cultural rite as a meal, referenced often by local critics when charting Cleveland’s pizza lineage. Go for a classic pepperoni and a carafe; leave with a story.

https://mamasantas.com/
Best Pizza in Cleveland (2025)

Information

Family-run Italian eatery serving thin-crust pizza & classic red-sauce dishes

Google Rating
4.5 (2.2K)
Yelp Rating
3.6
Placeholder

12301 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
See full details

3

Information

Family-run Italian eatery serving thin-crust pizza & classic red-sauce dishes

Google Rating
4.5 (2.2K)
Yelp Rating
3.6
Placeholder

12301 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
Mama Santa's by null
See full details

More Places For You

All Saints Public House

Bar · Detroit-Shoreway

Seasonal clambakes, craft cocktails, and a shaded patio

1 Postcard

GE Chandelier

Cultural landmark · Playhouse Square

Largest outdoor chandelier in US, a stunning landmark

0 Postcards

FWD | Forward Day + Nightclub

Night club · East Bank

Outdoor adults-only venue with pool, cabanas, dance floor

1 Postcard

Mitchell's Ice Cream (Ohio City Kitchen & Shop)

Ice cream shop · Market Square

Creative ice cream flavors, vegan options, viewing area

3 Postcards

Cent's Pizza + Goods

Pizza restaurant · Detroit-Shoreway

Wood-fired pizzas, wonder bread, unique cocktails, and retro vibes

4 Postcards

Cool World

Gift shop · Ohio City

80s heaven with vintage clothes, unique gifts, and a slide

1 Postcard

The Greenhouse Tavern

New American restaurant · Tower City District

New American fare, rooftop patio, creative cocktails, pig ears

1 Postcard

Mabel's BBQ

Barbecue restaurant · Tower City District

Exceptional smoked meat cooked low & slow with great bourbon selection

19 Postcards

Citizen Pie - Cleveland, OH

Pizza restaurant · Market Square

Neapolitan pizzas baked in a fiery oven, smoked pepperoni, colorful diner setting

1 Postcard

Tutto Carne

Steak house · Little Italy

Italian-themed steakhouse with classic dishes & extensive wine

2 Postcards