Takeout‑only, cash‑only, and legendary for overloaded toppings on whisper‑thin crust. OnMilwaukee’s pizza deep‑dive praises its spicy‑leaning sauce and generous sausage. It’s a north‑side ritual: call ahead, bring cash, and claim one of the city’s most old‑school tavern pies.
Best Pizza in Milwaukee (2025)
