1

Tuck Shop

Ice cream shop · Shelter Island Heights ·

Tuck Shop

Ice cream shop · Shelter Island Heights ·
@vogue
3,763 Postcards · 1,060 Cities

The Hamptons Guide: Vogue Editors Pick Their Favorite Restaurants, Hotels, Shops, and More | Vogue

"Shelter Island’s best ice cream shop has gotten subtle upgrades over the years but it’s never lost its no-frills charm; ice cream fans gather on the benches by the curb, spill into the parking lot, or take a seat in the appealingly cozy back lawn." - Elise Taylor

https://www.vogue.com/article/vogue-staffers-hamptons-guide

Information

Unique homemade ice cream flavors and hand-packed pints

ice cream sandwich
nice staff
old fashioned
summer on shelter island
no-frills charm
cozy back lawn
vogue editors' favorites
card minimum
Google Rating
4.5 (90)
Yelp Rating
3.7
Featured in Vogue
Featured in

75 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Get directions

$$

Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Coffee
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
See full details

1

Information

Unique homemade ice cream flavors and hand-packed pints

ice cream sandwich
nice staff
old fashioned
summer on shelter island
no-frills charm
cozy back lawn
vogue editors' favorites
card minimum
Google Rating
4.5 (90)
Yelp Rating
3.7
Featured in Vogue
Featured in

75 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Get directions

$$

Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Coffee
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
Tuck Shop by null
See full details

More Places For You

The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

Hotel · Shelter Island Heights

Waterfront resort with renovated cottages, pool, beach & dining

9 Postcards

The Chequit

Hotel · Shelter Island Heights

Luxe rooms, complimentary breakfast, cafe, trendy restaurant

3 Postcards

Marie Eiffel Market

Organic restaurant · Shelter Island Heights

Organic fare, bakery, market with dockside tables & harbor views

1 Postcard

Sunset Beach Hotel

Restaurant · Shelter Island Heights

Waterfront escape with chic decor, sunset views, and bikes

8 Postcards

Isola

Italian restaurant · Shelter Island Heights

Live music, burgers, pasta, and brick oven pizza

1 Postcard

Marie Eiffel LLC

Women's clothing store · Shelter Island Heights

Elegant boutique with curated clothing, accessories, lifestyle goods

1 Postcard

Shelter Island House

Bed & breakfast · Shelter Island Heights

Beach-chic rooms, pool, on-site bakery, and complimentary bike use

0 Postcards

Stars Cafe

Cafe · Shelter Island Heights

Organic coffee shop serving breakfast staples, sandwiches & salads

1 Postcard

North Ferry

Ferry service · Shelter Island Heights

Ferry connecting Shelter Island & North Fork, cash only

1 Postcard

Teakwood Thai Chophouse

Thai restaurant · Tribeca

Modern Thai restaurant reimagining steakhouse with bold flavors

3 Postcards