Butterfield Market

The market, situated in the Upper area, offers an array of fresh and appealing fare — the sort one might rather sensibly purchase in the morning and enjoy leisurely in Central Park, rather than dining immediately at a restaurant. The quality, I must say, was notably superior to that of markets in the lower part of town, perhaps owing to the more refined neighbourhood. There was a splendid selection of produce and provisions, and just as I arrived, fresh sushi rolls and salads were being newly displayed. Observing the local residents eagerly adding them to their baskets lent a certain trustworthiness to the offerings, and I found myself thinking that I should very much like to return here more frequently on future visits to New York. That said, the conduct of the staff left rather much to be desired. They were not especially attentive, nor did they convey any sense of warmth or regard for the customer — merely attending to their tasks with a sort of detached efficiency. Still, one might say that simply carrying out one’s duties is, in such places, quite sufficient. In the end, I was rather grateful that the establishment prioritised cleanliness and quality produce over polished service.

I WOULDN’T cater my Passover Seder or Easter or any other holiday meal from them. I live in the building above this “gourmet” grocery store. Last week two obnoxiously loud refrigerated trucks appeared and stayed parked there all week, refrigerator engines intermittently coming on all day and night, presumably to keep them cold inside. I didn’t know what they were there for. I only saw employees loading things in and out all week. Finally, on Saturday, they stuck a little canopied farmstand between the two trucks with a sign that read, “Holiday Meal Pick-Up Here” and began unloading the prepared meals from those trucks. Hope everyone enjoyed their “fresh” $800 dinner for 6 that had been kept in a fridge truck on the street in NYC for days. Shameful.

The reason why they are so expensive is cause there is nothing else in a 10 block radius, order delivery from saint Embreuse is cheaper. After reading the amazing review about the food quality I need to add that it’s above average for New York City super market but the bar is very low.

Cute store. Came for frozen yogurt, left for a million cakes and bread. Their flavor of frozen yogurt is very selected. I can’t come here anymore because they don’t let you bring your 3 pound dog in a purse or stroller (haters).

Butterfield Market is a gem in Uptown Manhattan. It offers a fantastic selection of fresh and gourmet foods, from deli items to bakery treats. The quality is consistently high, and everything tastes fresh and delicious. The market has a cozy, neighborhood feel, making it a pleasant place to shop or grab a quick bite. Prices are on the higher side, but the quality and variety make it worth it. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch, a cup of coffee, or some specialty groceries, Butterfield Market is a great choice.

Butterfield Market in NYC boasts a well-curated selection of items and a pleasant shopping atmosphere, but it falls short when it comes to value for money. The market offers a range of gourmet and specialty products that are appealing and high-quality, but the prices are notably high for what is being offered. Many items seem overpriced given their quality, which can be quite off-putting, especially if you're looking for good value. While the store's ambiance and the variety of products available are certainly commendable, the cost factor is a significant drawback. Shoppers might find themselves enjoying the experience and selection, but ultimately questioning whether the prices align with the quality. This discrepancy can make it challenging to fully appreciate the offerings, as the high cost may overshadow the otherwise pleasant shopping experience. If Butterfield Market can address the pricing issue, it could better meet customer expectations and enhance overall satisfaction. For now, while it's a nice place to explore, be prepared for a premium price tag that may not always match the perceived value of the items.

I don’t ever wanna go back to this place. I asked to try a sample of the frozen yogurt and the Spanish girl said she cannot give me a sample since she already gave me 2 flavors (one for me and one for my girlfriend). I’m not spending $20 for a frozen yogurt that I don’t know hot it taste. So rude of her!!

there’s a reason this place has a cult following. the BEST market on the upper east side. the best place to pop into if you want to grab a quick bite to eat or set up for a picnic to take to central park. the have so many varieties of pre-packaged and fresh pre-made food. good bakery section. large cheese and meats selection. sushi is so fresh. coffee is delicious. been coming here for years and will keep coming back anytime i’m in the area