Dowling's at The Carlyle

Restaurant · Upper East Side

Dowling's at The Carlyle

Restaurant · Upper East Side

5

35 E 76th St, New York, NY 10021

Photos

Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by Alex Staniloff/Dowling’s at the Carlyle
Dowling's at The Carlyle by Alex Staniloff/Dowling’s at the Carlyle
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null
Dowling's at The Carlyle by null

Highlights

Nestled within The Carlyle, Dowling's boasts stunning decor and a refined menu that might tempt you to splurge, but expect mixed vibes from the service.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder

35 E 76th St, New York, NY 10021 Get directions

rosewoodhotels.com
@dowlingsatthecarlyle

$100+

Reserve

Information

Static Map

35 E 76th St, New York, NY 10021 Get directions

+1 212 570 7192
rosewoodhotels.com
@dowlingsatthecarlyle

$100+

Reserve

Features

wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Jul 14, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Chef Sylvain Delpique cooks a three-course prix fixe for $165 per person. Seatings are from 11:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m reserved on Tock. The Easter Bunny will make an appearance at 12:30 p.m. and 2:30 p.m." - Melissa McCart

NYC Restaurants for Easter Sunday 2023 - Eater NY
View Postcard for Dowling's at The Carlyle
@exploretock

"Celebrate a new era of dining with the introduction of Dowling’s at The Carlyle. Newly appointed Executive Chef Sylvain Delpique (formerly of 21 Club) has created a menu that features his interpretations of timeless New York favorites and throwback dishes from another era. This latest addition to The Carlyle family is named after Robert Whittle Dowling, former owner of The Carlyle and an influential urban planner known for his passionate efforts over half a century ago to revitalize the city that never sleeps. He acquired the hotel in the 1940’s and was instrumental in turning it into the institution it is today and putting it on the map as a fashionable destination attractive to celebrities, politicians, royalty and tastemakers alike. It is through his whimsical vision that The Carlyle embodies a distinct sense of place, offering a welcoming, intimate and eclectic atmosphere for New Yorkers and visitors alike."

NEW YORK CITY CITY GUIDE
View Postcard for Dowling's at The Carlyle
@eater

"The famed Bemelmans Bar may garner all the attention at the Carlyle, but it’s not the spot for a proper sit-down dinner. The hotel’s restaurant, once simply called the Carlyle, was closed for nearly two years before it reopened in fall 2021 as Dowling’s. The kitchen, under the direction of former 21 Club chef Sylvain Delpique, nods to fine dining in the 1930s and 1940s with dishes like steak Diane and salt-crusted branzino filleted tableside." - Bao Ong

13 Hotel Restaurants in NYC Not Just For Tourists - Eater NY
View Postcard for Dowling's at The Carlyle
@eater

"The city’s many hotels are also home to some of the best dining rooms fully decked out for the holidays. Dowling’s at the Carlyle is the newest entrant and is perfect for diners seeking a cushy, sophisticated experience. Chef Sylvain Delpique, whose cooking celebrates timeless and nostalgic dishes, is serving a menu with classics like quiche Lorraine, croque-madame, and buttermilk waffles with caramelized apple pecan marmalade for brunch." - Beth Landman

Where to Eat on New Year’s Day in New York City - Eater NY
View Postcard for Dowling's at The Carlyle
@eater

"Dowling’s at the Carlyle — named for Robert Whittle Dowling, an urban planner who acquired the hotel in the 1940s — is all about mid-19th century nostalgia. It is helmed by Sylvain Delpique, the former executive chef at the legendary, now-shuttered 21 Club. The atmosphere in the 80-seat room, and many of the new dishes, are a nod to throwback Manhattan fine dining traditions in the 1930s and 1940s, with Dover sole and salt-crusted branzino filleted tableside. A flambe station adds dramatic flair to dishes like steak Diane, set on fire with a pour of cognac; and a flaming Grand Marnier sundae. A “butcher’s cut” section of the menu includes three cuts of steak alongside roast chicken. A pumpkin ricotta raviolo in hazelnut sage butter, containing egg yolk that bursts in diners’s mouths upon contact, is Delpique’s play on a much-lauded favorite at now-defunct Manhattan fine dining spot San Domenico. The restaurant will serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a carving station for prime rib — a weekend brunch highlight. “We are bringing back dishes that might have been forgotten,” says Delpique. “And there is a lot of interaction with guests, which is something many places don’t do anymore.” Under Delpique’s watch, the restaurant is making everything in-house now, from the bread to the smoked salmon, and foie gras terrine. The hotel with its adjoining restaurant, cafe, and bar is a NYC celebrity hotspot, having hosted such bold-faced names as Tom Cruise, Madonna, Lady Gaga, Anthony Bourdain, Lenny Kravitz, Princess Diana, and — just last month — Prince Harry and Meghan Markle. Controversial filmmaker Woody Allen has not only featured the hotel in his movies, but he has regularly performed with a jazz band at Cafe Carlyle on Monday nights. Prints and paintings from Ludwig Bemelmans adorn the walls in both the bar and — in a special addition for the reopening — the restaurant, too. Dowling’s at the Carlyle is open daily from 7 to 10:30 a.m.; 12 to 2 p.m.; and 6 to 10 p.m. The restaurant is open on Friday and Saturday until 10:30 p.m. Sunday brunch is served from 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. Reservations are available via Tock." - Beth Landman

The Carlyle Hotel Reignites Its Restaurant With Burning Nostalgia and Flaming Sundaes - Eater NY
View Postcard for Dowling's at The Carlyle

Hsiao-Hsuan Lu

Google
I visited today for their Restaurant Week menu. Based on their website and in-house menu, I chose the half-dozen oysters as my starter and steak frites as my main dish. However, when my order arrived, I noticed there were only three oysters. Upon asking, I was told that they had downsized the portion for the Restaurant Week menu—something that was not mentioned anywhere beforehand. This felt misleading. The steak was decent, but the portion was disappointingly small. Overall, it was a terrible experience. Given the overpriced menu, average food quality, and less-than-welcoming service, I won’t be returning.

Melissa Martella

Google
Dowling's was such a wonderful experience. The menu was so diverse and creative, and the service was exceptional. The wait staff and chefs were all so welcoming, kind and knowledgeable about the menu and ingredients. The food was so fresh and made to perfection.

Maggie J

Google
Had breakfast here two mornings in a row while staying at the hotel. The dining space is nice but had an unappetizing smell while I was there. Similarly, the breakfast was fine but nothing to write home about and both mornings it was over $50 for breakfast for one. It’s convenient when staying in the hotel and service is good but I wouldn’t come for a meal if I was not already in the hotel.

Gabriela E. Mendez

Google
Yummy food and great service. One of the best burgers in town. Now, this is a truly expensive restaurant where drinks can be $35+ so you’ve been warned. The environment has no natural light, so perhaps best for the winter months. This restaurant is regularly on restaurant week so plan accordingly.

Wuttichai Kailum

Google
Had a great time with friends at Dowling's at the Carlyle Attentive staffs, knowledgeable about the menu, accommodating to special requests, friendly and welcoming demeanor This restaurant offers excellent dinning experience

Wade Guenther

Google
First, the service is about as good as anyone would ever want. The main server was knowledgeable and helpful with menu choices. And the Captain was a local who gave great background information about the rich history of the restaurant and how your order was sourced. Dowling's was renovated and the decor is stunning. The atmosphere is amazing which keeps it far from the madding crowd of restaurants-in-hotels vibe. The tuna tartare was light, cheerful and a great way to start off. The dover sole is a rarity in the city. It is prepared and deboned table-side. It has a light, lemon, taste that melts in your mouth. Similarly, the lamb shank is tender and falls off the bone. Do not pass up on Dowling's at the Carlyle! The staff made us feel like VIPs. And the food backed it up. It was a wonderful experience that we will definitely have again.

Kate

Google
Dowling’s was a bit disappointing, and I don’t think I’ll return. I came here for happy hour with two friends after hearing it’s a nice spot to grab drinks and small bites on the Upper East Side. The drinks and truffle fries lived up to my expectations, as did the over-the-top colorful decor of the room where we sat. And I expected the prices to be expensive because this is inside The Carlyle, but $30 for an average cocktail was unwarranted, and the small bites were also egregiously priced with small portions. However, what was most bothersome was the snotty attitude of our table “captain.” He completely killed the experience. Our server was polite and friendly but nothing outstanding, and the pressure to tip both individuals at the end of our drinks was absurd. And all in, neither the menu or experience made this place merit a revisit.

A R

Google
We had an overall great lunch experience at Dowling's within the Carlyle. The food and service were great, and I absolutely loved the elegant decor of the dining room. This is a great spot on the Upper East Side!

Shari T.

Yelp
Insanely cute decor, fantastic food, exceptional service! My new fav restaurant! Ambiance, food, service, all amazing!

Jessica W.

Yelp
Firstly, I tried to call the restaurant for 45 minutes. No response , 5 calls from 7:36pm-8:15pm. We were going to be late for our resy. I explained to the hostess when we arrived that we tried to call numerous times, she responded it's hard to get to the phone after hours.. we arrived at 8:50.. but I called at 7:46. They take reservations up until 9:45, what exactly do you mean? The table they took us to had terrible lighting, and had crumbs on the booth seating side. Service was okay, busser and runners were good. Refilled my own sparkling water 2x despite a "captain" coming to the table with empty glasses. Food was TERRIBLE. Escargot, house made smoked salmon, ribeye and tartare. Ribeye was ordered med rare, came medium. Tartare, pretty bad and the tiny thin chips were stale tasting. Escargot in shell, with a weird sauce, no bread but croutons.. epic fail. The Somm was great, she knew her stuff. She's great.. everything else.. no. Cost VS quality? Wasted evening.

Miranda F.

Yelp
One of the snazziest choices for restaurant week! Fine dining for a fraction of the regular cost. Service was top notch. They didn't rush us out when we finished dessert and coffee leisurely on a rainy afternoon. The food was craft-fully prepared with fresh ingredients. Portions were larger than expected for a place of this caliber. The ambiance, however, is the main attraction! Just old-money New York to a T. Felt like a proper UES housewife. Would love to return for jazz!

June S.

Yelp
The dining room is quite magnificent. It looks like a different kind of museum or gallery. We were planning to go to the Metropolitan Museum of Art after lunch, so this put us all in the perfect "art mood." Their complimentary bread was one of the best I've ever had! We were not super hungry, but we devoured the bread... For food, we had Faroe Island Salmon, Carlyle Burger, Croque Madame, Heritage Bacon, and Truffle Fries. Everything we ordered was really tasty, we enjoyed them all. I had a high expectation for Dowling's, and they did not disappoint! The service was excellent, we were well taking care of from the beginning to the end. One of the staff even offered to take some photos of us, which was really sweet! The food was delicious, and we were all very full, we did not have any room for dessert, which was sad... We just have to go back there again!

Amanda W.

Yelp
Wonderful restaurant set in the beautiful Carlyle hotel! Loved the paintings and photographs all around the restaurant. The service was impeccable, the captain and the servers were all so attentive to our needs and did not feel rushed at all. We ordered two restaurant week menus and a main course. All to share. This was definitely enough for 4 people. The portions were good size, not small by any means! I was full at the end of the meal. By restaurant week, ordered: - kale and farro salad (I loved this but hubby is allergic to nuts and the captain did not mention or ask if anyone had allergies before the meal!! Big no no ! Luckily I noted the nuts! Hubby did not eat this. - tuna tartare: good and fresh - pekin duck (this was good but a bit chewy and fatty) - beef short ribs (this was excellent!) - crepes Suzette with grand marnier (excellent! And cooked table side - raspberry soufflé (could've skipped this, I generally love soufflés but raspberry was not the best flavor) Additionally also ordered Halibut - which was also blah. Cooked in a leeks and smashed potatoes, barely any sauce, just bland And asparagus side, this was good Overall, loved the service and restaurant but food was a mere passé.

Carmen B.

Yelp
Met my friends here for lunch and had a fantastic meal and time. Mirim saw to it that our dining experience at lunch was one for the books. Can't wait to come back.

Toby L.

Yelp
We went for brunch. The venue ( in the Carlyle hotel)is quite fancy and we had all put on smart outfits, you want to be fairly well dressed. The brunch was of course on the expensive side. Pancakes were decent. French toast was a big disappointment, one tiny bit of French toast on an empty plate for like $30 ha ha. Service also fell apart a little as they forgot one of our breakfasts, so 3 of us ate while my son sat there for 20 mins waiting. Also the pastry tray which we ordered to come first came out at same time as all the other food so a bit of a rush. Worth a visit, but you are basically paying for the name and venue.

Susan Allan B.

Yelp
I would have given this restaurant 5 Stars for food, service & the magnificent room, however the Carlyle Hotel, Bemelman's Bar & Dowling's have completely gutted their dress code standards. We ordered champagne, caviar, appetizers & table side steak Diane but had 3 loud young punks dressed in T'shirts & sneakers seated next to us half way through our dinner. My husband was wearing a jacket/tie & I was in a dress. The people in the bar weren't much better. It's beyond disrespectful to the hotel & those who dressed appropriately for a lovely fine dining experience. I was told that "standards" are changing everywhere because they are fostering the next generation of regulars. Really? That tells me that they don't want me or people like me to dine there anymore. If elegant places lower their standards they will get what they asked for. There my be a long line to get into the bar but if people were required to dress better they would either conform or not, but the bar would still be filled w/a higher clientele. It isn't too much to require a collared, button down shirt w/a jacket but allow jeans. And "ladies" - what's up w/the white sneakers? Can't you do better than that? Don't young people have any respect for themselves or others anymore? You may think you look "cool" but most of you look like you didn't even shower. Shame on you & all of the restaurants who have trashed their standards!

Maxwell H.

Yelp
This was an immaculate experience. I was sort of blown away. We came to celebrate my Mom's Birthday and from the get the service was excellent. I think what I enjoyed so much about this restaurant is that it's old fashioned, fancy dining (complete with captains, servers, tableside presentations, etc.) but it never felt stuffy and the portions were nicely sized. Compared to something like Daniel where you leave hungry and feeling like you couldn't laugh or smile, lest you be scolded by the staff or other patrons, this managed to be the perfect balance of elegant and fun. The room is beautiful and not too large. The bar attached to it was packed, and although the restaurant was full on a Friday night it didn't feel overly busy or too loud. I loved the paintings and art on the wall and the unique light fixtures and other décor touches. The service, as mentioned above, was top notch. Our captain was friendly, informed, and made us feel welcome and appreciated. The food was delicious. Everyone enjoyed their meal - the tuna tartare was lovely, the ribeye was cooked to perfection, someone at our table had the Steak Diane which they prepared tableside, the dover sole was presented and perfectly fileted by the table, a massive sundae was prepared and assembled tableside - just a fantastic experience throughout. It's expensive, of course. For special celebrations or those who want to splurge. But for us it was worth every penny, and I hope to find another excuse to come back soon.

Kathy G.

Yelp
Lovely brunch to celebrate my daughter's 21st birthday. Impeccable food and service in the most elegant of settings.

Liz M.

Yelp
Loved Dowling's!! It was beyond amazing. The food was delicious and the service was impeccable. The decor was lovely and the ambiance was sublime. We're looking forward to coming back to when we're in from California.

Gui F.

Yelp
I was there as part of Restaurant Week. The food was good but the overall experience was disappointing. First you have some security guy that is way too agressive and unwelcoming. Then they brought the appetizer and the main dish immediately (almost too fast IMO) but we waited 20+ min for the dessert: many staff noticed we were waiting but it's only after we inquire about it that they were brought up.

David B.

Yelp
This is one of those bucket list restaurants for those in NYC. Took us a few years to finally dine here and I'm glad we did. First and foremost, the service is top notch and very friendly. The atmosphere is incredible and a must see. Food was solid, but pricey as you might expect. All in all, I'd say it's worth it for a special occasion

Christel C.

Yelp
Probably the worst meal I've had in recent memory (potentially ever). The one star, if anything, is for the service and the festive decor. Service was fine and as expected from an establishment like the Carlyle. We went here for the pre-fix Christmas Day dinner - cost per diner was $300 (inclusive of a 10% "administrative fee" of which I hope a good part of this fee / cost goes to the individuals working during and through the holidays) not including alcohol. Presentation-wise everything looked fantastic and as expected (again) for a place like the Carlyle. Execution on the food itself was extremely lacking. For anyone who has given the food 3 stars or more - it's astounding and I have to imagine that they've bamboozled themselves into believing it was good because of the fine dining / premium flair of the restaurant and hotel. The Bad: the leg of lamb was under salted and partially too well done and the mint chimichurri that came with it just gave the plate color (no taste and was not complementary) - the only distinguishing taste was the gaminess of under salted lamb, roasted chicken was dry / tough and again under salted - texture was like sand, the chocolate cake of the bouche de Noel tasted old and as if it was pre-made several days in advance, the duck pâté came sliced in a baked pastry which was cold and congealed / compacted with the fat of the duck with no discernible taste other than that of a deli meat. The Okay / Good: wine selection, martini, soufflé, service Overall, at the price point and reputation of the Carlyle I expected a lot more (even if the overall cost is baking in the premium of eating out / getting served during the holidays). The final pile on / annoyance was how they managed the line at Bemelmans (hotel bar next to Dowling's) - the host / individual managing the long line to get in basically shouted to everyone multiple times: "you have no chance of getting in here unless you're a guest of the hotel" - if that's the case, then why would you mark it as "open" and should've just put a sign out saying "hotel guests only" - no class for a classy(???) establishment like the Carlyle.

Aarti K.

Yelp
What's not to love about this place! Beautiful ambience, sumptuous food, delightfully attentive staff and oh the live music playing in the background . I'd pick this place every time I'm around central park.

Kevin M.

Yelp
The most exciting new restaurant post-pandemic! This place ticks all the boxes, brilliant chef Sylvain Delpique reinvents and elevates American and European classics in an intimate art-filled dining room. The staff are super professional and fun especially when they're finishing preparations tableside. From the original Cocktails to an after-dinner cognac, this is the place NYC has been waiting for.

Emily K.

Yelp
Underwhelming food, okay service, and much ado about tableware. Even with "prixe fixe" Restaurant week $39 2- course lunch you'll pay a server tip and captain tip, and when you tell them your dessert doesn't taste right, they won't refund you for it or offer to switch it out. So many better options for a classy, expensive lunch, don't bother coming here.

Ivy C.

Yelp
In the mood for a classic, elegant dining experience? Dowlings is the place to go. Impeccable service transcending time in a spot known for serving Jackie O and the Kennedys, Princess Diana and today's Royales. The atmosphere is old school restaurant eatery with a mixture of funky art and eclectic floral arrangements. It was formal yet cozy. There was staff for each compartmentalized function with rolling carts to prepare food that is flambeed, deboned and otherwise plated table side. The food was very good, especially the salt crusted Branzino, white gazpacho and hamachi crudo. This is a great place for a celebration, a romantic meal, a get together with friends, a business meal.

Ipsita D.

Yelp
It's a nice enough space of course, given that it's in the Carlyle hotel, but the food & drink are very overpriced given that they are nothing to write home about. My friends & I went for brunch. I tried the pumpkin-ricotta raviolo (which is a single raviolo for $27) as an app and another friend tried the avocado toast (which she asked to be topped with egg whites instead of a poached egg), both were good but we have had better elsewhere. I had the salmon eggs Benedict as a main--the English muffin was hard and the poached egg was overcooked. My friends tried the roasted eggplant over bulgar, which they said was just all right. For drinks, one friend had a mocktail (which she liked, but was $25!), another had a gin & tonic ($28!) and I had their "Mr Gray" cocktail (also $25--this was very strong but the taste only ok). Given the high price point, we were fairly disappointed with the quality. Came out to over $90 per person. I've come to the Carlyle before a few years ago for dinner and I wasn't that impressed then either; don't think I'll be returning. There are so many better restaurants in NYC that are better value and quality.

Vaishnvi S.

Yelp
Nestled in the historic Carlyle Hotel, is Dowling's Restaurant. It has stunning interiors with gorgeous framed artwork lining the inside. Brightly lit and inviting, the interiors are a spectacle of their own. It is one of the few remaining old school establishments which retains the classic fine dining structure of tables being serviced by Captains, Servers, and Bussers - all of whom are delightfully kind and warm. You are welcomed with warm bread and butter and serviced like royalty for the rest of your meal. The food was spectacular and the drinks are strong. I highly recommend ordering the table side Sundae to finish off your meal, dinner and a show. Overall, perfect.

Herve S.

Yelp
Over priced, over hyped. They really mean well but haven't gotten their act together yet. Food just OK, service good. Some day may make it. Bring a load of cash.

Hongyi G.

Yelp
This is the worst dinner experience ever, I feel the service is terrible and the food is so overpriced and not worth the money. First of all, the steak that we ordered on that night, it was totally disgusting, the meat is not cooked properly and you can't taste any spice and flavor of the meat. And the desert is even worse, I barely eat nothing good at that night, I just feel the service is really terrible too, we were waiting for them to get a spoon around 20 minutes.

Morgane S.

Yelp
Thanks for ruining our anniversary. My partner made a reservation two weeks ago to celebrate our anniversary. It's restaurant week and we love trying new places and experiences. It's 90 degrees outside so my boyfriend wore a collared short and shorts and I wore a dress. Upon walking in we were instantly stopped by a security guard who told my boyfriend he was wearing shorts and the restaurant host would turn us away. The restaurant host then proceeded to tell us we should of looked at the website to see there is a dress code (I booked through google reservations and someone called to confirm and never ONCE mentioned a dress code). He then said "fine, I'll sit you in the corner." Thanks for making us feel like scum and embarrassing us on a special night.

Kathy K.

Yelp
It's the Carlyle!! Food is quite good, service divine and the experience memorable!

Bill H.

Yelp
Had breakfast in early Oct -2021 after their recent renovation. Very good foods, attentive staffs and nice looking interior.

Edwin H.

Yelp
after reading the recent reviews of the reopening of the Dowling restaurant at the Carlyle and having had fond memories of many enjoyable dinners we chose this as our place to celebrate my wife's 84th birthday with friends. This was one of the most horrible evenings we've experienced at a restaurant. Unless you are a masochist do not, do not, contemplate having dinner at this restaurant. Aside from the wonderful Tatinger rose champagne friends ordered everything was completely downhill. It is not a luxurious restaurant and somewhat unattractive. There were four of us having dinner and I could only barely talk to the person next to me since the noise level was horrendous. The captain/waiter who informed me he had been there many years and therefore I expected the kind of service we we were used to in the past. His attention was nonexistent. 45 minutes after we had soup we still had not received our dinner. I got up from the table and went in search of our captain/waiter and when I told him he was not doing a very good job of -"where was our food ?"his response was "see the manager". We complained many times to the manager and etal. and our food still did not come out- they told us it was being cooked. Finally the three parties who ordered fish were served. I never received by lamb shank- a number of complaints to the manager and other people still do not produce my dinner. I asked my wife for a piece of her fish and decided to give up my dinner. We had complained to the captain, waiters, manager, and on and on. At that point we decided we had to leave my wife had a headache I was getting to be furious with what was going on and the ruination of what was supposed to be a lovely evening. Finally they brought out my lamb shank after we had finished the fish I refused thr meal. I told the manager I had no intention of paying for the dinner and I wanted to see the hotel manager. Eventually before we left the food and beverage manager of the hotel came out I explained what happened - he apologized which did not help in any way and said this is not what we should've expected. I told him I would not pay for the dinner and he said he understands and we ran as fast as we can out of this madhouse. in conclusion do not contemplate going near this restaurant.

S. M.

Yelp
Con artists when it comes to the wine. An absolute rip-off. They charge for ONE glass of wine what you pay in a store for the entire bottle. Food is not bad, but it is absolutely nothing special. Especially during restaurant week. Even if they take great pride in the theater of table-side preparation.

Diem L.

Yelp
Food has become legit delicious and my favorite place for a fancy UES lunch. I had quite possibly the single best lobster bisque and lobster sandwich in nyc! An Old New York institution with so much history.

Bob D.

Yelp
They lost my reservation and didn't ask for a vaccination card. The margarita was great...but $29? The food looked good, and even my water glass was beautiful, but the roast chicken and olive oil whipped potatoes were virtually tasteless. (And I don't have Covid.) I skipped dessert.

Carly L.

Yelp
Dowlings is lovely and my dining experience was wonderful. The food was creative and delicious and the service is unmatched. I just started a new job in the neighborhood so all of the Carlyle restaurants are going to quickly become regular spots for me. Dowlings is also perfect for special occasions. The decor is interesting and you can just feel the history of the building. Everyone who waited on us was super attentive and accommodating. The next time someone visits me from out of town I will definitely be taking them to Dowlings for a guaranteed exquisite meal!

Maryann M.

Yelp
The atmosphere is amazing and the food was fabulous. The Dover Sole was superior and the addition of a crab cake appetizer highlights the talents of the chef. Creative wine and champagne list. A great evening and dining experience. We cannot wait to return.

Rrrr S.

Yelp
I hate to say it but it's like "a new paint job on an old clunker." I could do a drink by drink and course by course rundown of why this fell short of my expectations...but the truth is that those who are mimicking the warm, lounge-y Americana dining rooms of the 60s like the Polo Bar or 4 Charles Prime, are doing it better than the original. From the menu to the service, it all feels tired. It's a shame because it has/has so much potential.

Rebecca B.

Yelp
The dreamiest lemon butter sauce accompanied the branzino dish. Pricy meal but the food and atmosphere were great.

Jack W.

Yelp
Average at best. The diners next to me had a steak and he said to me that he could cook something better at home... I was used to the old Carlyle. this isn't it.

Andrea R.

Yelp
Very "old New York" fine dining. Pretentious and overpriced. The flaming table side steak Diane and Dover sole made me feel like I was in Las Vegas or Disneyworld. Maybe a 4 star cruise ship