"Owner Craig Melillo’s passion for ice cream rivals his skills as a pizzaiolo. Like his pizzas, his ice cream flavors change often based on what’s available from Oregon and Washington farms, as well as his own creative whims: One week you might find a lightly savory bay leaf, the next a buttermilk ice cream with orange-ginger jam, the next a silky honey ice cream with pops of pink peppercorn. Regardless of the flavor, Gracie’s ice creams are consistently luscious — not sticky or tacky, not too firm, just satin smooth." - Michelle Lopez
"Served as the 2021 pop-up venue where Pastificio grew before opening a full-service space in November 2022, and later received a direct shoutout from the couple: “And, of course, Gracie’s Apizza.”" - Thom Hilton
"At Gracie’s Apizza, a rye sourdough starter imparts a noteworthy tang to Pacific Northwest grain establishing the canvas for a rotating selection of fun touches or seasonal treats. Pies drizzled with Oregon green garlic arrive alongside pizzas topped with a handful of hazelnuts and homemade mozzarella, accompanied by a classic, intentionally simple tomato pie; for those looking for something different, Gracie’s calzone is also one of the city’s finest." - Ben Coleman
"This St. Johns pizza shop has an open kitchen where you can watch and chat with the owner, who’ll turn out close to 70 Neapolitan wood-fired pies per night. The pace here can be leisurely, but you won’t even mind once you take a bite of something off their short, sweet menu. It always includes a margherita and tomato pie that goes minimal with sauce, garlic, oregano, and grated pecorino, and is so flavorful you won’t miss the mozzarella. Take a seat near the dogwood wallpaper (locally made, of course) and snack on some marinated olives while you wait for the hazelnut pie, with unexpected hits of herbal flavor from tangerine sage, bay leaf cream, and tangerine oil. Order whatever the daily pie is—that’s where you’ll find seasonal touches like sugar snap peas and cubed melon that’s an ingenious stand in for pineapple." - krista garcia
"This St. Johns pizza shop has an open kitchen where you can watch and chat with the owner, who’ll turn out close to 70 Neapolitan wood-fired pies per night. The pace here can be leisurely, but you won’t even mind once you take a bite of something off their short, sweet menu. It always includes a margherita and tomato pie that goes minimal with sauce, garlic, oregano, and grated pecorino, and is so flavorful you won’t miss the mozzarella. Take a seat near the dogwood wallpaper (locally made, of course) and snack on some marinated olives while you wait for your pie to emerge. Order whatever the daily pie is—that’s where you’ll find seasonal touches like sugar snap peas and cubed melon that’s an ingenious stand-in for pineapple." - Krista Garcia