Daniel L.
Yelp
Came in for an early Fathers Day dinner with my family. This was a Michelin recommended restaurant. I have been to several 1, 2, and 3 star Michelin star restaurants throughout the world, but this has got to be the worst food I have eaten and the service was horrible. I am not even sure how this place was Michelin recommended, unless they knew beforehand the Michelin reviewer was coming and made an exception meal for him or her.
The service started off nice, we were greeted and seated and then the rest went downhill from there. There was only one server in the entire restaurant and she was just over worked I assumed. We all asked for water with ice and lemons. Well the water came but no lemons. My sister, my nephew, my brother as well as me asked the waitress 4 separate times for lemons...well we never got lemons. Next we all placed orders from the menu including food, wine and appetizers. She recommended several appetizers which we ordered. The roasted broccolini was undercooked and barely edible. We couldn't even cut it. For $18 I would give it a zero star. Next we ordered the grilled octopus. It was tough as well, I have eaten really good grilled octopus, but this was not one. For $28 I would rate this a 1 star. The grilled carrots were good, but for a few pieces and $16, I would not order again. The crudo ie aged kampachi was really good, 4 stars for this dish. The flavor and texture were good. The special appetizer of the night was beef tartare and it fresh and smooth tasting, 4 star for this dish as well. The wedge salad wasn't anything special either, presentation looked nice but taste wise, it wasn't anything special than I could make at home. We didn't get any WOW from any of the appetizers.
As for the entrees, we ordered lasagna, the burger, seabass, halibut, wagyu, and the rack of lamb. The lasagna was quite spicy and tasted bland but the flavor just wasn't there. Let's just say nothing I would have expected from a Michelin recommended restaurant. The burger was cooked well, but hey how can you mess up on a burger. Burger was cooked to perfection and tasted great. The seabass was really good as well. It was tender and the sauce was amazing. The halibut tasted good and the meat was flakey and overall cooked well. The Knights Valley Wagyu was a huge disappointed, it was basically inedible. For me being a meat eater I expected amazing. This wasn't even close to thst. For $180 for the plate you would think it would melt in your mouth, but it was super chewy and had zero flavor. We couldn't even cut the steak with the knife. It would have been nice if they gave us a steak knife rather than a butter knife. Honestly this was the worst piece of steak I have ever eaten. I mean Outback steak was better and more tender than this and I don't even like Outback steaks. A real disappointment for our entire table. We also ordered the rack of lamb which was cooked well, but it was just way too gamey for our liking. I have had amazing rack of lamb at other restaurants in the past that was not gamey...this restaurant was not one.
For desserts we tried four selections...the mandarin creamsicle, the pistachio tart, the tiramisu and the affogato. The mandarin creamsicle was very good, the rest was just average.
In the end they forgot the entree for one person in our party. My sister NEVER got her entree. We kept asking the waitress and she said it was coming and was getting rude with our party. In the end she asked if we wanted to just take it home, since they totally forgot her order. Normally most restaurants I have been to would apologize and comp that entree, but not Maligne, no apologies from our waitress, they just ended up taking it off our final bill since my sister never received her entree. Disappointment all around.
They ended charging us a mandatory tip of 22% for a party of 9. We would NOT have tipped 22% because not only was half our food inedible but the service was horrible. The waitress had a horrible attitude and just asking her simple questions she just wasn't attentive and never even smiled. No way could this restaurant ever get a Michelin star in my opinion. I would give an A for presentation, but that's about it. Anyone can make a meal look good to the eye, but making it taste good is another story. Maligne missed the mark on food and service and I would highly NOT recommend this place if you are staying in Monterey. There are many other restaurants in Monterey you can choose from. For a meal that was over $1300 I would have expected more.