Toby's Supper Club

American restaurant · East Side

1

@eater

"Madison’s dining scene is great for its unexpected global diversity, but it is also a city in Wisconsin, and what city in Wisconsin worth its salt doesn’t have at least one great supper club? Other areas of the country unfamiliar with the term might think of Toby’s as a steakhouse or just an old-school restaurant, but the supper club is a true Wisconsin shibboleth. Get literate on relish trays, brandy old fashioneds sweet (this grammar is our answer to Philly’s “Whiz wit,’” so say it right), Friday fish fry, and boozy ice cream drinks. Toby’s has been doing it for decades, and they know how to take care of you Wisconsin-style." - Kyle Nabilcy

Where to Eat in Madison, Wisconsin

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718 Get directions

tobyssupperclub.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Nattspil

Eclectic restaurant · First Settlement

This cash-only speakeasy delights with global small plates and quirky cocktails in a cozy, laid-back vibe, making for an unforgettable night out.

0 Postcards

Fairchild

Fine dining restaurant · Dudgeon-Monroe

Tucked away on Monroe Street, Fairchild is a cozy spot serving up inventive meat, seafood, and pasta dishes, all paired with delightful cocktails.

4 Postcards

It's Good For You

Pizza Takeout · Emerson East

This cozy counter-service gem whips up authentic Neapolitan pizza in a wood oven, serving up fresh ingredients and a solid drink selection.

2 Postcards

Best Western Premier Park Hotel

Hotel · Downtown

Perched across from the Wisconsin State Capitol, this stylish hotel combines comfort with convenience, offering modern amenities and a lively atmosphere just steps away from Madison's vibrant social scene.

0 Postcards

The Old Fashioned

Restaurant · First Settlement

This retro Wisconsin tavern serves up a hearty mix of local brews and classic bites, with their renowned cheese curds taking center stage.

3 Postcards

Mint Mark

New American restaurant · Schenk-Atwood

Nestled in a charming blue brick building, this laid-back spot serves delightful small plates and boasts an impressive cocktail menu, perfect for sharing.

6 Postcards

Mickey's Tavern

Bar & grill · Marquette

This cozy neighborhood bar boasts delicious pub fare, friendly service, live tunes, a pool table, and a charming patio, perfect for a laid-back hangout.

1 Postcard

Graduate by Hilton Madison

Hotel · State-Langdon

Nestled just steps from UW-Madison, this vibrant hotel boasts cozy, collegiate-themed rooms and a rooftop bar, perfect for soaking up the local charm.

0 Postcards

Gotham Bagels

Bagel shop · Mansion Hill

Gotham Bagels serves up delightful New York-style bagels and sandwiches from a charming spot in Chicago, winning hearts with their soft, chewy perfection.

2 Postcards

Graze Restaurant

American restaurant · First Settlement

This vibrant gastropub offers a stylish space with Capitol views, serving up must-try farm-to-table comfort dishes in a delightful atmosphere.

2 Postcards