Toby's Supper Club

American restaurant · East Side

1

@eater

"Madison’s dining scene is great for its unexpected global diversity, but it is also a city in Wisconsin, and what city in Wisconsin worth its salt doesn’t have at least one great supper club? Other areas of the country unfamiliar with the term might think of Toby’s as a steakhouse or just an old-school restaurant, but the supper club is a true Wisconsin shibboleth. Get literate on relish trays, brandy old fashioneds sweet (this grammar is our answer to Philly’s “Whiz wit,’” so say it right), Friday fish fry, and boozy ice cream drinks. Toby’s has been doing it for decades, and they know how to take care of you Wisconsin-style." - Kyle Nabilcy

Where to Eat in Madison, Wisconsin

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718 Get directions

tobyssupperclub.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Mint Mark

New American restaurant · Schenk-Atwood

Nestled in a charming blue brick building, this laid-back spot serves delightful small plates and boasts an impressive cocktail menu, perfect for sharing.

6 Postcards

Johnson Public House

Coffee shop · Tenney-Lapham

Coffeehouse serving java, sandwiches & sweets in an art-filled, vintage brick storefront.

1 Postcard

The Harvey House

Restaurant · Preglers Addition

At Harvey House, chic old-school vibes meet upscale Wisconsin supper club classics, all served with impeccable service in a stylish redbrick setting.

4 Postcards

Graze Restaurant

American restaurant · First Settlement

This vibrant gastropub offers a stylish space with Capitol views, serving up must-try farm-to-table comfort dishes in a delightful atmosphere.

2 Postcards

Ogden's North Street Diner

Breakfast restaurant · Emerson East

Nestled in a cozy neighborhood, Ogden’s North Street Diner serves up comforting breakfast staples and inventive specials in a charming, bustling setting.

1 Postcard

Marie's Soul Food

Restaurant · Vilas

Marie's Soul Food is a cozy spot serving up addictive Southern classics like rib meals, catfish, and collard greens, with perfect fried chicken stealing the show.

2 Postcards

Blue Moon Bar & Grill

Bar & grill · Regent

Relaxed, 2-level art deco bar with signature burgers & cheese curds plus a jukebox & billiards.

1 Postcard

Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse

Steak house · First Settlement

Delmonico’s is an upscale steakhouse that effortlessly combines classic surf 'n' turf with a retro charm, offering a cozy yet vibrant atmosphere for a memorable dining experience.

1 Postcard

Lao Laan Xang Restaurant

Laotian restaurant · Schenk-Atwood

Lao Laan-Xang is a cozy spot on Atwood Avenue dishing out comforting Laotian dishes like their must-try curry squash and flavorful khao tod nam som lettuce wraps, perfect for a casual meal before a show next door.

2 Postcards

Cento

Italian restaurant · Downtown

Cento brings the essence of Italy to Madison with its housemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and an impressive wine list, all served in a lively, upscale environment perfect for both casual and special occasions.

1 Postcard