Toby's Supper Club

American restaurant · East Side

2

@eater

Where to Eat in Madison, Wisconsin

"Madison’s dining scene is great for its unexpected global diversity, but it is also a city in Wisconsin, and what city in Wisconsin worth its salt doesn’t have at least one great supper club? Other areas of the country unfamiliar with the term might think of Toby’s as a steakhouse or just an old-school restaurant, but the supper club is a true Wisconsin shibboleth. Get literate on relish trays, brandy old fashioneds sweet (this grammar is our answer to Philly’s “Whiz wit,’” so say it right), Friday fish fry, and boozy ice cream drinks. Toby’s has been doing it for decades, and they know how to take care of you Wisconsin-style." - Kyle Nabilcy

https://chicago.eater.com/maps/best-restaurants-madison-wisconsin-food-road-trip

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718 Get directions

tobyssupperclub.com

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Ahan

Southeast Asian restaurant · The Isthmus

Pan-Asian dishes, craft cocktails, excellent dole whip & soft serve

7 Postcards

Art Gecko State

Jewelry store · State-Langdon

Vast ring selection, friendly staff, unique crafts

1 Postcard

Short Stack Eatery

Breakfast restaurant · Warrens Addition

Elevated breakfast favorites, milkshakes & Bloody Marys

1 Postcard

Graduate by Hilton Madison

Hotel · State-Langdon

Chic collegiate hotel with rooftop bar & cafe.

0 Postcards

Bar Corallini

Italian restaurant · Schenk-Atwood

Hand-crafted pasta & pizza, vegan options, robust wine list

2 Postcards

Johnson Public House

Coffee shop · Tenney-Lapham

Coffeehouse serving java, sandwiches & sweets in art-filled space

1 Postcard

Garver Feed Mill

Event venue · Schenk-Atwood-Starkweather-Yahara

Craft kombucha, pizza, ice cream, cocktails, coffee & events

1 Postcard

Hotel Ruby Marie

Hotel · First Settlement

Period rooms, free Wi-Fi, breakfast & happy hour at eateries.

0 Postcards

Fairchild

Fine dining restaurant · Dudgeon-Monroe

Creative meat plates, seafood, pasta, cocktails & wine.

4 Postcards

Gotham Bagels

Bagel shop · Mansion Hill

Big chewy bagels, BEC sandwiches, & lox cream cheese

2 Postcards