Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

Cookie shop · Greenwich Village

1

@eater

"East Village: Captain Cookie & the Milk Man, a cookie company with locations in Washington, D.C., and Raleigh, North Carolina, is calling it quits in New York City. “We have taken a step back from retail after our past year of serving East Village and Times Square,” a company spokesperson tells EV Grieve. The bakery opened on Broadway last April." - Luke Fortney

NYC Restaurant Closings, April 2023 - Eater NY

741 Broadway, New York, NY 10003 Get directions

captaincookienyc.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Bandits Diner + Dive

Bar · West Village

Step into Bandits, a retro-inspired cocktail bar in Greenwich Village where tater tots and inventive cocktails meet a lively ’70s vibe for a fun night out.

10 Postcards

Pisillo Italian Panini

Italian restaurant · Financial District

This cozy spot dishes out massive Italian sandwiches bursting with flavor from quality imports, ensuring you'll leave with leftovers in tow.

11 Postcards

Noz 17

Sushi restaurant · Chelsea

Nestled in Chelsea, this cozy seven-seat omakase invites you to savor an innovative 30-course feast of exquisite Japanese flavors.

21 Postcards

San Sabino

Italian restaurant · West Village

Nestled in the West Village, San Sabino dazzles with its stylish decor and tempting Italian menu, where standout dishes like lobster triangoli and a cozy atmosphere make for a delightful dining experience.

14 Postcards

Wildair

New American restaurant · Lower East Side

Wildair, the laid-back sibling of Contra, serves creative small plates and natural wines in a bustling Lower East Side space that’s always a scene.

55 Postcards

Mango Bay

Restaurant · Fort Greene

Mango Bay is a vibrant Caribbean restaurant in Fort Greene, Brooklyn, where stunning flavors meet stylish decor, creating a fresh twist on classic dishes.

6 Postcards

Surreal Creamery

Ice cream shop · Kips Bay

Surreal Creamery is a vibrant dessert haven in Kips Bay serving gigantic, Instagram-worthy bubble tea floats and elaborate mason jar ice creams, perfect for your next sweet adventure.

3 Postcards

Bagel Pub

Bagel shop · Crown Heights

Bagel Pub is your go-to Brooklyn bagel spot with an overwhelming selection of fresh bagels, inventive spreads, and a relaxed vibe perfect for brunch or a quick bite.

5 Postcards

Fat Fowl

Caribbean restaurant · Downtown Brooklyn

Fat Fowl at Dekalb Market Hall serves Caribbean-inspired rotisserie chicken and savory sides like oxtail grilled cheese, in a vibrant, casual setting.

3 Postcards

Peter Luger Steak House

Steak house · Williamsburg

At Peter Luger, a storied Brooklyn steakhouse since 1887, old-school charm meets sizzling porterhouse perfection, served in a wallet-ready, cash-only atmosphere.

60 Postcards