3

Third Time's the Charm

Bar · Red Hook ·

Third Time's the Charm

Bar · Red Hook ·
@eater
391,575 Postcards · 10,993 Cities

NYC New Restaurant Openings, October 2025 | Eater NY

"The pizza pop-up’s brick-and-mortar spins full pies ($28–$33) and cheeky snacks—from a “cold ‘carbonara’” to battered, fried onion petals dubbed the “trademark infringement”—with a full bar and $12 martinis daily from 4 to 5 p.m." - Tierney Plumb

https://ny.eater.com/restaurant-openings/405068/nyc-new-restaurant-openings-october-2025

Information

Sourdough pizzas, craft cocktails, crushable beers, and bar bites

sourdough pizza
pizza
cocktails
blooming onion
trademark infringement
heated backyard
lime pizza
gluten-free
Google Rating
4.9 (47)
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in

275 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$30–50

See Menu
Restroom
Credit card accepted
Alcohol
Wine
Beer
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
See full details

3

Information

Sourdough pizzas, craft cocktails, crushable beers, and bar bites

sourdough pizza
pizza
cocktails
blooming onion
trademark infringement
heated backyard
lime pizza
gluten-free
Google Rating
4.9 (47)
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in

275 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$30–50

See Menu
Restroom
Credit card accepted
Alcohol
Wine
Beer
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
Third Time's the Charm by null
See full details

More Places For You

Pangat

Indian restaurant · Park Slope

Authentic Indian dishes, goat biryani, regional pop-ups, backyard patio

2 Postcards

Nasrin's Kitchen

Persian restaurant · Midtown West

Authentic Persian cuisine, tender kebabs, fragrant rice & stews

11 Postcards

Cinemixology Room

Cocktail bar · Williamsburg

Craft cocktails inspired by iconic films in speakeasy

3 Postcards

LELECHA(Tea and Bakery)

Bubble tea store · Midtown West

Inventive bubble teas, rich dirty buns & flaky egg tarts

2 Postcards

Monsieur

Bar · East Village

Dramatic medieval-themed cocktail bar with gothic vibes and pub fare

6 Postcards

Gnocchi on 9th

Italian restaurant · Upper East Side

Freshly made gnocchi served in iconic takeout boxes

2 Postcards

Ask For Janice

Bar · Greenpoint

Inventive cocktails, great music, and Italian-American food.

7 Postcards

Instant Noodle Factory

Ramen restaurant · Long Island City

DIY instant noodles with 100+ global flavors & toppings

5 Postcards

Bad Hombre

Mexican restaurant · East Village

Coastal Mexican seafood, natural wine, cocktails, and ribs

3 Postcards

Fat Choy

Vegan restaurant · Lower East Side

Vegan Chinese dishes like mushroom sloppy and salt & pepper cauliflower

17 Postcards