"Known for its classic prepackaged ice cream cake sold in grocery frozen aisles, this $12 cake delivers a compact, nostalgic celebration at an affordable price. Layers of chocolate and vanilla are separated by the brand’s signature “crunchies” (crushed cookie bits) that add essential textural contrast, while a marshmallow icing stays soft and fluffy in the freezer without becoming overly gooey when warmed on the plate. A brightly dyed ring of icing and pastel sprinkles complete the look; the cake may cling to the cardboard disc it was piped onto at the factory, but it slices fairly soft straight from the freezer and withstands mild freezer burn, remaining enjoyable over several days — an easy, low-effort treat when larger celebrations aren’t possible." - Amy McCarthy