Bagel Supreme

Bagel shop · Fort Hamilton

1

@eater

"This Bay Ridge bakery offers a bagel so big and bulbous, that the holes have nearly disappeared — one is almost enough to be shared by two. The shop furnishes views of the nearby Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, and there’s a park across the street where you can eat your purchases in fine weather. (It also sells subs on rolls baked on the premises.) Its most unusual product is the French toast bagel, which is sweet, sticky, and covered in powdered sugar." - Robert Sietsema, Eater Staff

The Best Bagels in New York City
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

9401 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209 Get directions

bagelsupreme.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Hungry Thirsty

Thai restaurant · Gowanus Heights

Hungry Thirsty in Brooklyn brings a fresh spin on Thai cuisine, serving vibrant, Southern-inspired dishes in a lively, fun atmosphere.

9 Postcards

ACRU

Restaurant · Greenwich Village

Experience the extraordinary at ACRU, where Chef Daniel masterfully crafts creative, beautifully plated dishes amid cozy elegance in the West Village.

9 Postcards

The Clubhouse Cafe

Coffee shop · Concourse

Nestled near Yankee Stadium, Clubhouse Café combines tasty brews from Devoción with a vibrant community vibe, offering young Bronx locals invaluable job training.

3 Postcards

Shukette

Middle Eastern restaurant · Chelsea

Shukette is a vibrant Chelsea eatery where chef Ayesha Nurdjaja serves smoky Levantine fare, featuring must-try frena bread and lively shareable plates.

24 Postcards

Bad Habit Ice Creams

Ice cream shop · East Village

Nestled in the East Village, Bad Habit Ice Creams boasts an inventive scoop shop with velvety hot chocolate and unique ice cream flavors that'll keep you coming back.

15 Postcards

La Gran Uruguaya Restaurant

Uruguayan restaurant · Jackson Heights

La Gran Uruguaya is a vibrant South American eatery in Jackson Heights that pairs traditional dishes and baked goods with a lively atmosphere and local charm.

1 Postcard

Black Label Donuts (popup, follow online)

Donut shop · Flushing

Experience gourmet doughnuts like no other at Black Label's pop-up in Bayside, blending global flavors and clever creativity—follow on IG for updates!

1 Postcard

El Barrio Burritos

Mexican restaurant · Crown Heights

A vibrant spot for California-style burritos and tacos, where friendly staff serve up flavorful dishes that brighten your takeout game.

1 Postcard

Crane Club

Steak house · Chelsea

Crane Club is a stunning new addition to NYC, offering impeccable food, friendly service, and a lively ambiance for an unforgettable dining experience.

12 Postcards

Bad Roman

Italian restaurant · Upper West Side

Bad Roman, a vibrant addition from Quality Branded in the Time Warner Center, serves whimsical Italian-American fare in a playful, maximalist setting that’s equal parts fun and fabulous.

27 Postcards