5

Tortelli

Italian restaurant · Gowanus Heights ·

Tortelli

Italian restaurant · Gowanus Heights ·
@grubstreet
13,517 Postcards · 1,477 Cities

The Best New Restaurants in NYC

"As the weather chills, there may be no more in-demand tables than the four outside at this Carroll Gardens pasta shop from the chef behind LaRina and Briscola. The titular tortelli arrives in a very buttery pesto, while cavatelli is bathed in a sugo of heirloom tomatoes; some items are exclusive to the dine-in experience, like fresh frizzled snap peas served over ricotta with croutons. Eating at Tortelli feels like overindulging at the farmers’ market without the work of cooking, and there are affordable wines by the glass or bottle to finish the domestic, market-like meal." - Grub Street

https://www.grubstreet.com/2025/09/best-new-restaurants-nyc-september-2025.html

Information

Fresh pasta shop with dine-in, take-home, and provisions

fresh pasta
homemade pasta
tortelli
friendly service
cavatelli
tagliatelle
tiramisu
takeout
Google Rating
4.6 (41)
Yelp Rating
3.6
Rated 7.7 by The Infatuation
7.7
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

359 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Good for solo dining
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
See full details

5

Information

Fresh pasta shop with dine-in, take-home, and provisions

fresh pasta
homemade pasta
tortelli
friendly service
cavatelli
tagliatelle
tiramisu
takeout
Google Rating
4.6 (41)
Yelp Rating
3.6
Rated 7.7 by The Infatuation
7.7
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

359 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Good for solo dining
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
Tortelli by null
See full details

More Places For You

Strange Delight

Seafood restaurant · Fort Greene

New Orleans-inspired seafood spot with oysters, shrimp, and fried dishes

42 Postcards

Rowdy Rooster - East Village

Fast food restaurant · East Village

Indian-inspired fried chicken sandwiches & street food

29 Postcards

The Buttery Bar

Wine bar · Greenpoint

Wine, cocktails, elevated comfort food, and bookish events

5 Postcards

Yemenat

Yemeni restaurant · Bayridge

Authentic Yemeni food, specializing in slow-cooked lamb haneeth

11 Postcards

Milu

Chinese restaurant · Battery Park City

Crispy duck rice bowls, pineapple buns, and chili crisp chicken

3 Postcards

Chateau Royale

Restaurant · Greenwich Village

Classic French dining with tableside cocktails and escargots

13 Postcards

Chola

Indian restaurant · Midtown East

Coastal Indian cuisine: seafood, curries, tandoor, vegan

8 Postcards

In Sheep's Clothing NYC

Bar · SoHo

Hi-fi listening bar & record store with custom sound system

3 Postcards

Bar Mercer

Restaurant · SoHo

Raw bar, small plates, hearty mains, and excellent cocktails.

6 Postcards

Maison Nur

French restaurant · Lower East Side

French-American dining with caviar, caviar, steak au poivre

4 Postcards