1
"A mainland supermarket in Bay Shore that the family orders groceries from; purchases are delivered to the island by ferry to stock the household for the summer." - Alan Sytsma, Margalit Cutler
Market with deli, bakery, organics, and fresh produce.
533 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Get directions
$$
Restaurant · Bay Shore
Island-inspired cocktails, diverse cuisine, and a lively beachy vibe
2 Postcards
Mexican restaurant · Bay Shore
Refined Mexican fare, seasonal margaritas, cool greenhouse dining
1 Postcard
Seafood restaurant · Bay Shore
Seafood-heavy outpost serving signature chowders, burgers & sandwiches
Bar · Bay Shore
Chicken sandwiches, cocktails, beers, and event hosting
New American restaurant · Bay Shore
Seasonal fare with global accents, full bar, and outdoor seats
0 Postcards
Japanese restaurant · Bay Shore
Sushi, teppanyaki, and lively hibachi shows with outdoor seating
Bagel shop · Bay Shore
Bagels, deli salads, cold meats, coffee, pastries
Bakery · West Village
Artisanal bakery with pastries, breads, pizzas, and sandwiches
13 Postcards
Wholesaler · Astoria
Gourmet Spanish ingredients, cheese, cured meats, olive oil, seafood
Restaurant · West Village
Pastel murals, fuzzy stools, disco ball, natural wine
5 Postcards