A Review of Stilwell Hotel, Carmel-by-the-Sea| Hotels Above Par

"Opened in May 2024, this sleek boutique property sits about two blocks from Ocean Avenue and marries modern design with coastal comfort. Guests are welcomed by an outdoor fireplace and a stylish yet relaxed lobby featuring dark wood finishes, soft neutrals, and contemporary furnishings. Rooms range from cozy singles to spacious suites, some with balconies, small courtyards, fireplaces, or tubs; the Carmel Bay Suite is a standout with ocean views, multiple seating areas, and a notably impressive bathroom. Large windows fill rooms with natural light and vistas of the mountains, neighborhood, and sparkling sea. The hotel’s outdoor spaces are a major draw — intimate courtyards with ivy, a soothing fountain, glowing overhead lights, and perpetually lit fire pits surrounded by comfortable sofas and umbrella-shaded tables create a warm, communal atmosphere. Practical perks include an arrival welcome drink, included breakfast, luggage and golf-club storage, concierge and 24-hour front desk service, pet-friendly and ADA-accessible rooms, complimentary parking with EV charging, and select rooms with gas fireplaces. Overall the property balances upscale, chic touches with a laid-back Carmel vibe, making it a polished yet welcoming base for exploring the coast."