The Grey Barn and Farm

The 21 Best Restaurants On Martha’s Vineyard - Martha's Vineyard - The Infatuation

"This Chilmark favorite has been open since 2009—it’s a farm, it’s a bakery, and, yes, it’s got farmstead cheese. Visit the farmstand for freshly baked bread, sweet treats, orange rind-covered Prufrock cheese, milk, preserves, and meats raised right on the farm. It’s a great stop to stock up on a ton of stuff for your visit to the island, because starting your day with a freshly baked pastry and snagging some bread and cheese for later is the correct life choice. The fact that there is excellent cheese being made completely on-island, with milk from their very own herd of cows, is nothing short of miraculous—swing by and peep the creamery operation yourself." - morgen schroeder, tanya edwards