The Best New Pizza In NYC - New York - The Infatuation

"Lucia of Avenue X is, you guessed it, right on Avenue X in Sheepshead Bay, and if you live within delivery distance of this place, you'll want to order from here at least a couple times a month. The crust on their round pizzas isn’t too flimsy, but it’s also not so crunchy that your plate will be covered in crumbs. All their pies are available by the slice, and our favorites are the vodka and the grandma. And, while hot honey is already past the point of being played out, we’d still recommend their Caramelle Piccanti with cherry peppers, little roni cups, and that spicy sweet condiment. This spot has a few tables and chairs, and we suggest making good use of their seating by eating any slice you get here fresh out of the oven." - bryan kim, neha talreja, kenny yang