Cait's Key Lime

Bakery · Downtown Brooklyn

1

@infatuation

"The next time you find yourself at a rooftop barbecue or a park hang, bring a key lime pie. When everyone else unveils their store-bought guac and chips or six-pack of canned wine, you’ll be the hero, especially if the pie is from Cait’s Key Lime. These pies are made to order and come in three sizes, Goldilocks-style. The filling is smooth and pudding-like, with an ideal combination of tartness and sweetness, and each pie is topped with a generous layer of whipped cream and zest. There’s no physical storefront, but you can order the larger sizes online for pickup or delivery, or find mini pies at Sweet Chick locations around town. photo credit: Britt Lam" - Britt Lam

Cait’s Key Lime - Review - Brooklyn - New York - The Infatuation
Britt Lam

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

caitskeylime.com
@caitskeylime

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Angelina's Kitchen

Italian restaurant · New Springville

Angelina's Kitchen blends family tradition with a cozy ambiance, serving up delicious Italian fare like wood-fired pizzas and heartfelt pasta dishes that make you feel right at home.

2 Postcards

Raines Law Room Chelsea

Cocktail bar · Chelsea

Enter through a discreet bell to discover this cozy lounge serving exquisite Prohibition-style cocktails, all in a warm, inviting ambiance.

7 Postcards

Vatan

Indian restaurant · Kips Bay

Vatan brings the charm of a Gujarati village to Midtown, serving up an exuberant all-you-can-eat vegetarian feast amidst a canopy of vibrant murals and a faux banyan tree.

9 Postcards

The Bronx Beer Hall

Bar · Belmont

Nestled in the bustling Arthur Avenue Retail Market, the Bronx Beer Hall is a lively spot to sip on local craft brews while savoring delicious Italian bites, with a fun karaoke vibe on the side.

6 Postcards

Toshi's Living Room

Fine dining restaurant · Midtown West

This vibrant live-music spot in the Flatiron Hotel combines eclectic decor with delicious bites and friendly service, making it an ideal hangout for a fun night out.

2 Postcards

12 Matcha

Cafe · NoHo

Nestled in the East Village, 12 Matcha is a trendy café and retail haven, showcasing exceptional ceremonial-grade matcha and delightful treats from a Japanese tea farm.

3 Postcards

Little Ruby's West Village

Restaurant · West Village

Discover Little Ruby's Cafe, a cozy West Village eatery where all-day brunch classics meet Aussie flair, featuring ricotta hotcakes, hearty pastas, and a lively atmosphere.

2 Postcards

Peter Luger Steak House

Steak house · Williamsburg

A cash-only classic, Peter Luger serves up perfectly aged steaks in a nostalgic German beer hall vibe, making every bite a culinary trip back in time.

60 Postcards

Flor de Mayo

Peruvian restaurant · Upper West Side

Flor de Mayo effortlessly fuses vibrant Peruvian and Chinese flavors in a bustling Upper West Side spot that's perfect for group dinners and killer cocktails.

5 Postcards

Mango Bay

Restaurant · Fort Greene

Mango Bay serves up a vibrant fusion of Caribbean and Asian flavors, with stellar service and a fun atmosphere that keeps diners coming back for more.

6 Postcards