"If you live near Made In New York Pizza, consider yourself lucky. Maybe even go outside and plant a tree or say something nice to one of your neighbors in order to pay it forward. Once you’re done with that, come here and get a slice. The margherita is delicious, as are the white square and the upside-down slices covered in a sweet tomato sauce - but the best thing here is the square pepperoni slice. It’s crispy on the bottom and covered in thick pepperoni cups, and the dough isn’t so thick that it feels like you’re just eating a big piece of bread with toppings on it. This is some of the best pizza on the UWS, and there are a bunch of tables inside if you don’t feel like carrying your food all the way home." - hannah albertine, matt tervooren
