"Relocated from East Hampton Village to Amagansett in fall 2023, Rowdy Hall 2.0 is bigger and arguably better than it ever was. The contentious black exterior aside, there’s a spacious dining area, a bar playing Knicks games, plus an excellent backyard. It’s all about the pub food here—a giant fluffy Bavarian pretzel and buffalo wings, crisp and spicy with a tangy sauce that’s not too intense. The homemade ice cream is worth visiting for, too: creamy, soft, and available in seasonal flavors with your choice of toppings to dress up as a sundae." - melissa kravitz hoeffner, team infatuation