Pickler Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Midtown East

1

@infatuation

"Pickler & Co is one of the greatest discoveries we’ve had in Midtown recently. It’s a “craft deli,” meaning it’s a deli that wishes it were in Brooklyn, but nonetheless stays true to traditional deli values (for example: there is avocado toast, but it’s only $4). They put a lot of care into what they do here, including their BEC. You get to pick your egg (white or regular), cheese, meat, bread - and there are plenty of sauces to spice things up as well. We went classic, and were very satisfied with our sandwich. BEC Power Points: Lots of choices to customize (because sorry, no one actually chooses American cheese). Penalties: It could be bigger. Served Until: 11:30am We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Team Infatuation

Pickler & Co. - Review - New York - The Infatuation
Infatuation - Reviews

216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017 Get directions

picklernyc.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Smør Bakery

Bakery · East Village

This cozy East Village bakery serves up freshly baked Nordic delights like the fragrant cardamom bun and chèddar morning buns, perfect for a laid-back treat.

4 Postcards

Tasty Dumpling

Chinese restaurant · Chinatown

Nestled across from Columbus Park, Tasty Dumpling serves up a delightful array of budget-friendly dumplings, renowned for their flavor and charm in a no-frills setting.

8 Postcards

Dyckman Dogs

Hot dog restaurant · Inwood

Located on bustling Dyckman Street, Dyckman Dogs serves up Instagram-worthy hot dogs and loaded fries with a lively atmosphere and late-night vibes.

2 Postcards

Black Oak on Fifth

Italian restaurant · Park Slope

Charming Park Slope spot serving wood-fired pizzas and scrumptious pastas with a lively atmosphere perfect for family gatherings and sports fans alike.

1 Postcard

Jacob Restaurant

Soul food restaurant · Central Harlem

Dive into all-you-can-eat deliciousness at Jacob Restaurant, a Harlem buffet where you can load up on soul food favorites like crispy fried chicken and sweet yams for just $6.49 a pound.

2 Postcards

Bunna Cafe

Ethiopian restaurant · Bushwick

Bunna Cafe is a lively Ethiopian gem in Bushwick, serving vibrant vegan feasts packed with flavor and an inviting ambiance perfect for gatherings.

17 Postcards

Gem Home

Home goods store · Nolita

Gem Home in Nolita is a stylish café and market boasting fresh sandwiches and vintage finds, perfect for a casual bite or quaint browsing.

4 Postcards

Sunday In Brooklyn

American restaurant · Williamsburg

This cozy American eatery blends a lively marketplace atmosphere with attentive service and serves up delightful pancakes that are practically a brunch legend.

31 Postcards

Kabawa

Restaurant · East Village

Welcome to Kabawa, where inventive Caribbean cuisine meets warm, attentive service in an intimate, vibey setting that guarantees a memorable meal.

2 Postcards

Bar Pisellino

Bar · West Village

A charming West Village café and wine bar serving up authentic espresso, delightful hot chocolate, and tasty aperitifs, with inviting sidewalk seating.

32 Postcards