"Umberto is a counter-service slice joint on Hanover that opens exactly at 10:45am and closes when they run out, which is usually around 12:30pm. They make thick, square Sicilian pies and nail the style—the crust is surprisingly light, and the sauce settles into the airy pockets, creating that perfect blend of bready, tomato goodness with just the right amount of cheese. The slices are also all around $2, making it the cheapest option on this list." - tanya edwards