12

First Slice Pie Cafe

Pie shop · Andersonville ·
@infatuation
132,805 Postcards · 3,235 Cities

Where To Preorder Thanksgiving Pies In Chicago - Chicago - The Infatuation

"First Slice in Andersonville has some of our favorite sweet pies like chocolate peanut butter and pumpkin, and some great vegan ones, too. But they also have a few savory options like chicken or turkey pot pies if you don’t want to deal with carving a bird this year. You can see their whole selection and place an order here." - john ringor

https://www.theinfatuation.com/chicago/guides/where-to-preorder-thanksgiving-pies-in-chicago

Information

Specializing in fruit & cream pies, quiche, sandwiches, salads

Google Rating
4.7 (870)
Yelp Rating
4.3
Rated 7.7 by The Infatuation
7.7
Featured in Eater
Featured in

5357 N Ashland Ave STE 1R, Chicago, IL 60640 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Free street parking
Paid street parking
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by Jack Li
First Slice Pie Cafe by
First Slice Pie Cafe by Susie Lacocque
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
See full details

More Places For You

Omakase Box

Sushi restaurant · Logan Square

Omakase counter, handrolls, fresh sushi, approachable vibes

3 Postcards

Greenstar Brewery

Brewery · Lakeview

Certified organic brewery with craft beers, vegan food, and roof garden

2 Postcards

M Lounge

Bar · South Loop

Candlelit lounge with martinis, live jazz, and luxe seating

5 Postcards

Valois Restaurant

American restaurant · Hyde Park

Comfort food cafeteria, Obama's favorite, cash only, huge portions

18 Postcards

Alinea

Fine dining restaurant · Lincoln Park

Avant-garde tasting menus featuring theatrical presentations and innovative cuisine

262 Postcards

Spirit Tea

Tea wholesaler · Belmont Gardens

Specialty tea wholesaler offering handmade, rare loose-leaf teas

3 Postcards

sugargoat

Bakery · West Town

Sweets shop with unusual flavors like Cheez-It and french fry pie

12 Postcards

Smoque BBQ

Barbecue restaurant · Old Irving Park

Tender brisket, ribs, pulled pork & savory sides. BYOB.

41 Postcards

Fat Peach Bakery

Bakery · Bridgeport

Inventive laminated pastries, premium espresso, and unique desserts.

10 Postcards

Il Culaccino - Chicago Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant · South Loop

Italian dining with cocktails, wine bar, and seasonal outdoor seating

10 Postcards