"This City Island spot does a $25 all-you-can-eat Sunday Supper, which includes unlimited garlicky focaccia, iceberg salad, and bucatini swimming in a deeply savory tomato sauce, with tender sausage, and big, dense meatballs. Unless you’re a full-time City Island resident, getting to this cozy, green painted restaurant will be a journey, but we can’t really think of a better way to spend a Sunday evening. But you could come here with a group any night of the week for chicken parm, a few glasses of something red and Italian, and a couple of pizzas—we like the Red Hot Chili Pepper, with n’duja and spicy sausage." - willa moore, sonal shah, neha talreja, bryan kim, carina finn koeppicus