"The smashburger is everywhere, but the bar smashed meatball parm can only be found at Bar Madonna in Williamsburg. It's got stretchy provolone cheese and a crisp skirt, and you can wash it down with a martini or a limoncello milk punch in a green banquette. The cocktails are great here, but the food is the main draw." - willa moore, molly fitzpatrick, sonal shah