Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant · Neptune City

4

@infatuation

"Asking anyone in Jersey about where you can find the best bar pie might fire up an argument on par with debates about what happened after the screen went black in the final episode of The Sopranos. For us, though, Carmen’s Pizzeria at Pete & Elda’s stands above the rest. Get the XXL, and not because you want the t-shirt you get for finishing it. The paper-thin crust is perfectly crisp, and do your best to finish it all onsite because, unlike The Sopranos, leftover thin crust pizza doesn’t stand the test of time. " - Michael Sinatra

Where To Eat Down The Shore: Atlantic Highlands To Seaside Heights - New York - The Infatuation
@TheInfatuation

96 Woodland Ave, Neptune City, NJ 07753 Get directions

peteandeldas.com
@pete_eldas

4 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Palmer's Quality Meats

Butcher shop · Neptune City

Palmer's Quality Meats is the go-to butcher for fresh, pasture-raised meats and unbeatable sandwiches, all served with a side of friendly vibes.

2 Postcards

Bada Story, Fort Lee

Korean restaurant · Fort Lee

Bada Story is a cozy Korean haven known for its fresh sushi and sashimi, perfect for casual or special occasions with a hint of authentic charm.

1 Postcard

B-Prime Steakhouse

Steak house · Atlantic City

B-Prime Steakhouse at the Borgata offers a modern twist on classic steakhouse dining, featuring global-inspired cuts and an upscale yet inviting atmosphere.

1 Postcard

DOMODOMO Jersey City

Sushi restaurant · Jersey City

Nestled in a sleek new tower, this elevated eatery serves up exquisite nigiri and sushi rolls with outdoor seating for a perfect casual date night.

6 Postcards

Beach Club Victorian

Guest house · Beach Haven

Tucked in Beach Haven, this charming Victorian B&B boasts pristine en-suites, an inviting pool, and bike access—all just a short stroll to the beach.

0 Postcards

WÜRSTBAR

Gastropub · Jersey City

Discover Wurstbar in Jersey City, a lively eatery that serves an inventive mix of sausages, hearty burgers, and a solid beer selection in a rustic-chic setting.

5 Postcards

Anthony David's

Italian restaurant · Hoboken

Anthony David's is a charming Hoboken eatery offering delicious Italian-inspired brunch and dinner, with delightful patio seating perfect for enjoying the bustling streets.

2 Postcards

Corto

Italian restaurant · Jersey City

Nestled in the neighborhood, this airy eatery serves up inventive seasonal Italian dishes with homemade pasta and a vintage charm that's hard to resist.

14 Postcards

Mack's Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Wildwood

Family-owned pizza place on Wildwood Boardwalk baking a variety of thin-crust pies for 50+ years.

3 Postcards

Booskerdoo Coffee & Baking Co. Asbury Park

Coffee shop · Asbury Park

This cozy, family-run gem serves up delicious breakfast sandwiches, fresh pastries, and specialty coffees with a warm, inviting vibe.

1 Postcard