"Tucked behind Lucia Pizza of Soho—one of the city's top slice shops—is Lucia Alimentari, a tiny sit-down spot where they make personal pies (ranging from $18 to $25) and pour natural wine by candlelight. Everything is made in the slice shop, then slid through a window. Get a creamed spinach and/or vodka pie, one of the rotating small plates and desserts, and lots of Italian wine. Now that you’re in on the secret, go share it with someone. And book a little in advance if you want a primetime reservation." - bryan kim, molly fitzpatrick, willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah