"Thoroughly audible crunch and the presence of enough oats to be a horse’s breakfast would typically book any cookie a one-way ticket to the trash can. But Sea Wolf’s gloriously clunky puck is the exception to the rule. The way this hefty disc balances nutty brown butter, dark chocolate, and a heavy hand of sea salt gets us on board with its rock-hard texture quickly—and even makes us want to host a cookie convention and invite them as the keynote speakers. Their chat would touch on disrupting the industry, of course." - aimee rizzo, kayla sager riley