NYC for Aussie First Timers

@katiecroll
 on 2021.12.28
40 Places
@katiecroll
Here is a list of things to eat, see, and do aimed at first timers who've hauled across the globe for 24 hours to the greatest city in the world. Not exhaustive or definitive, but will set you on the right track. Its my "NYC.Doc" in a much sexier format

Lafayette Grand Cafe & Bakery

French restaurant · NoHo

I'm all about the eclairs

Via Carota

Italian restaurant · West Village

Everything is fantastic, particularly the cacio e pepe.

Attaboy

Cocktail bar · Lower East Side

The platonic ideal of a cocktail bar.

Lilia

Italian restaurant · Williamsburg

Book ahead for perfect pasta in a built-out garage space. Hits include mafaldini, agnolotti and fettuccine with lamb sausage and please, if nothing else, finish with the glorious soft serve.

Daily Provisions

Restaurant · Gramercy

It's hard to think of a better casual drop-in breakfast than a cheesy egg gougere and a cinnamon cruller.

Dominique Ansel Bakery

Bakery · SoHo

Worth the hype in so many ways. Pre order a cronut but, also, the New York Brest and DKA are essential.

Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream

Ice cream shop · Greenwich Village

You'll be overwhelmed by the variety of flavours, but it's very hard to make an incorrect decision here.

Westlight

Cocktail bar · Williamsburg

If you are looking for a rooftop bar with the best view, here it is. Go up ready for sunset and snap away.

Pasquale Jones

Italian restaurant · Nolita

Pizza and wine. A classic Margherita and the clam pie are the go-tos.

Veselka

Ukrainian restaurant · East Village

An instiution for good reason, stop by for some late night (or anytime!) pierogi. Get some boiled, get some fried. A great decision

Nakamura

Ramen restaurant · Lower East Side

Ramen. Delicious ramen.

Momofuku Milk Bar

Permanently Closed

The cereal milk softserve is truly one of a kind and gets better with every spoonful.

Petee's Pie Company

Pie shop · Lower East Side

Very good pies by the slice.

Hole In The Wall

Restaurant · Financial District

A classic Australian - style breakfast / brunch - the scrambled eggs, the benedict with pulled pork and perfect coffee will get you off to a ripper of a day to explore downtown.

Gramercy Tavern

Restaurant · Gramercy

Eat in the buzzy, lively Tavern Room that balances old school New York fancy and kinda casual at the same time.

Cafe Habana

Cuban restaurant · Nolita

Split a serve of corn and a cubano with your travel companion and thank me later.

Sam's Falafel Stand

Falafel restaurant · Financial District

Hands down, the best cart food in NYC.

Ops

Pizza restaurant · Bushwick

If you are a sourdough lover like I am - Ops delivers on the tangy, chewy crust of your dreams.

Doughnut Plant

Donut shop · Lower East Side

Holds a special place because this is where we got doughnuts instead of cake for our wedding. Multiple locations, many favorite doughnuts.

Barbuto

Italian restaurant · West Village

The Kale Salad. The Roast Chicken. The Potatoes. A carbonara or gnocchi = the iconic Barbuto meal.

Bemelmans Bar

Bar · Upper East Side

Outrageously priced beverages, but an iconic NYC experience.

The Four Horsemen

Restaurant · Williamsburg

Wine bar with tasty food!

Black Seed Bagels

Bagel shop · East Village

The best bagels around. The BEC on an everything bagel is my pick.

Shake Shack

Hamburger restaurant · DUMBO

I mean, every burger place that's opened in the past 10 years has taken inspiration from this icon. Obviously, plenty of locations.

yelp

Sunday In Brooklyn

American restaurant · Williamsburg

Your order here are the epic pancakes and the egg and cheese sandwich, add sausage.

Chez Ma Tante

Bistro · Greenpoint

The pancakes are great and you should go eat them.

Wildair

New American restaurant · Lower East Side

The drinks are good. The food is good. The vibe is good. Don't skip the Paris Brest or Wildair Tart.

Los Tacos No. 1

Taco restaurant · Chelsea

The Adobada especial and the pollo mula are my top picks, but it's very hard to go wrong with anything here.

yelp

L'Artusi

Italian restaurant · West Village

We come here everytime we visit, generally hoping for a seat at the bar sometime after 9:30pm. Consistently satisfying pasta and sides in the West Village. Get the Brussels sprouts, the mushrooms,a couple of pastas and the olive oil cake.

Hometown Bar-B-Que

Barbecue restaurant · Red Hook

Our go-to move is a late lunch, timed to the Ikea ferry (a 5 min walk away) that you can catch back to Manhattan. The best 5 dollars you'll ever spend that get's you a ferry ride across the iconic harbour. Get the lamb ribs, the burnt end baked beans and brisket.

Levain Bakery

Bakery · Upper West Side

Yes, they are as good as everyone tells you, the original and the best. You want to get the walnut chocolate chip, I promise. Nothing like grabbing one to split and taking it for a walk through the park.

Maman

Coffee shop · Tribeca

On your second cookie stop in the city, head to Maman for the nutty chocolate chip cookie.

Little Collins

Cafe · Midtown East

Not the only Australian coffee joint in NYC by any means, but certainly the best.

yelp

The Ten Bells

Wine bar · Lower East Side

There are endless happy hours in the city but this is my favourite for wine and oyster happy hour.

Scarr's Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Chinatown

The perfect slice on the Lower East Side, just be careful not to burn the roof your mouth when it's fresh out of the oven.

yelp

Emily West Village

American restaurant · West Village

The burger, the Emily, the Colony. Sorted.

Cookshop

American restaurant · Chelsea

This is a solid neighbourhood spot to make you feel like a local over brunch

Frenchette

French restaurant · Tribeca

Everything you want in a French Brassiere, particularly the pistachio Paris Brest.

Rubirosa Ristorante

Pizza restaurant · Nolita

The vodka "pie" is an icon for a reason, another solid Italian joint

Lil' Frankie's

Pizza restaurant · East Village

Lively pasta joint that is batting overs in the East Village

@katiecroll
Katie Croll
Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.