Italian Restaurants in St. Petersburg

Chef-owner David Benstock’s modern Italian landmark delivers handmade pastas and a chef’s counter tasting; recognized by the Michelin Guide and spotlighted by local tourism and food media for elevating St. Pete dining.

A family-owned downtown fixture known for tableside Bada Bing pasta and generous hospitality. Frequently recommended by locals and reservation platforms, it remains a go-to for classic Italian-American comforts.

Neighborhood stalwart since 1999 from chef-owner Frank Schittino, serving Sicilian-leaning pastas and red-sauce favorites. Praised by local food writers over the years for consistency and warm, personal service.

Downtown taverna channeling South Italy with cocktails, handmade pastas, and Roman-style pinsa. Praised by St. Petersburg Foodies and covered by local outlets for lively ambiance and neighborhood-first ethos.

Beloved Italian market with a bustling cafe, fresh pasta, espresso bar, bakery, and wine room. Lauded by the Tampa Bay Times and trusted by locals for a taste of Italy from lunch to pantry staples.

Casual Neapolitan spot turning out hand-stretched pies that earned national notice from Italy’s 50 Top Pizza, highlighted by Visit St. Pete/Clearwater. A relaxed, editor-approved choice for stellar pizza and salads.

Italian wine bar and contemporary Neapolitan pizzeria led by Naples-trained pizzaioli. Covered by I Love the Burg for its high-hydration doughs, imported ingredients, and house pastas.

A Beach Drive favorite since 2005, blending Old World flavors with a lively waterfront vibe. Regularly recommended by local guides and reservation platforms, and still locally owned.