5

The Old Fashioned

Restaurant · First Settlement ·

The Old Fashioned

Restaurant · First Settlement ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Capitol Square’s ode to Wisconsin taverns serves a wood-grilled burger on a buttered hard roll with Bavaria bacon and cheddar. Frequently recommended by Madison Magazine and Travel Wisconsin; the cheese curds are essential.

https://theoldfashioned.com/food
Best Burgers in Madison (2025)

Information

Wisconsin tavern with local beers, brats, cheese curds & Old Fashioneds

cheese curds
old fashioned
wisconsin fare
great location
beer selection
fish fry
walleye sandwich
burger
Google Rating
4.5 (4.7K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in

23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

$20–30

See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by Nicole Hansen
The Old Fashioned by Nicole Hansen
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
See full details

5

Information

Wisconsin tavern with local beers, brats, cheese curds & Old Fashioneds

cheese curds
old fashioned
wisconsin fare
great location
beer selection
fish fry
walleye sandwich
burger
Google Rating
4.5 (4.7K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in

23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

$20–30

See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by Nicole Hansen
The Old Fashioned by Nicole Hansen
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
The Old Fashioned by null
See full details

More Places For You

Atelier

Hair salon · Tenney-Lapham

Expert haircuts, coloring, facials, and brow waxing

2 Postcards

Bar Corallini

Italian restaurant · Schenk-Atwood

Pizza, pasta, vegan options, robust wine list, & cozy vibe

4 Postcards

Mint Mark

New American restaurant · Marquette

Produce-forward small plates, creative pastas, and a sharp cocktail program

12 Postcards

MACS (Macaroni And Cheese Shop) Madison

Restaurant · Far West Side

Mac 'n' cheese skillet sandwiches, salads, and desserts

1 Postcard

Greenbush Bar

Bar · South Campus

Sicilian-style pizza & pasta, wine & spirits in a basement parlor

3 Postcards

Paul's Pel'meni

Dumpling restaurant · State-Langdon

Russian dumplings with beef or potato, served with sour cream

5 Postcards

L'Etoile Restaurant

Fine dining restaurant · First Settlement

French-inspired American fare, wine & cocktails in airy venue

8 Postcards

Ahan

Southeast Asian restaurant · The Isthmus

Lao comfort cooking, creative Southeast Asian, James Beard semifinalists

10 Postcards

Camp Trippalindee

Restaurant · State-Langdon

Camp-themed eatery with burgers, s'mores, craft beers & views

2 Postcards

Marigold Kitchen

Cafe · First Settlement

Creative breakfast & lunch fare with outdoor seating

6 Postcards