St. Elmo Steak House

Steak house · Wholesale District

6

@postcardnews

Since 1902, this independently owned landmark has defined downtown dining with dry‑aged steaks and its famously fiery shrimp cocktail. A James Beard America’s Classics honoree and a perennial pick for visiting athletes, performers, and food writers.

https://www.stelmos.com/hours/
Best Restaurants in Indianapolis (2025)
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by You Gotta Try This (@yougottatrythis)

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225 Get directions

stelmos.com
@stelmosteakhouse

6 Postcards

Reserve
See full details

More Places For You

Loom

Bar · Mozel Sander Projects

Bar with laundromat, pinball, vintage games, and beer

1 Postcard

Chef Tia & Co "on the go"

Restaurant · Lake Maxinhall

Honey hot wings, loaded fries, seafood mac & cheese, catfish

2 Postcards

World Famous HotBoys Fountain Square

Chicken restaurant · Fountain Square

Nashville hot chicken, tenders & fries with customizable spice levels

1 Postcard

Bovaconti Coffee

Coffee shop · Fountain Square

Stylish coffee shop with great coffee, unique drinks, and patio

1 Postcard

King Dough

Pizza restaurant · Indianapolis

Brick-oven pies, hot honey, local beers, and outdoor patio

3 Postcards

Dorman Street

Bar · Woodruff Place

Cocktails, craft beer, pool table, jukebox, and patio seating

2 Postcards

Beholder

Fine dining restaurant · Woodruff Place

World-inspired small plates feature truffle bucatini.

5 Postcards

The Alexander

Hotel · Indianapolis

Hotel with custom artwork, massage, bar, and dining

1 Postcard

The Workingman's Friend

Bar & grill · Mount Jackson

Giant smash burgers & cocktails in an old-school space

2 Postcards

HI-FI Indy & HI-FI Annex

Live music venue · Fountain Square

Great sound, friendly staff, local brews, and diverse stages.

1 Postcard