2

Red Key Tavern

Bar & grill · Mozel Sander Projects ·

Red Key Tavern

Bar & grill · Mozel Sander Projects ·
@postcardnews
20,018 Postcards · 1,279 Cities

A rule‑bound, cash‑only classic dating to 1933—model planes, 45s on the jukebox, and legendary burgers. Celebrated by Esquire’s Best Bars list, praised by Indianapolis Monthly, and documented in the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. ([esquire.com](https://www.esquire.com/food-drink/bars/a2947/bestbars2007/?utm_source=openai), [indianapolismonthly.com](https://www.indianapolismonthly.com/food-and-drinks/drinks/holy-lit-red-key-tavern-lands-on-buzzfeed-list/?utm_source=openai), [indyencyclopedia.org](https://indyencyclopedia.org/red-key-tavern/?utm_source=openai))

https://www.redkeytavern.com/
Best Bars in Indianapolis (2025)

Information

Cash-only neighborhood saloon with great burgers & classic vibe

Placeholder
Placeholder

5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
payment cash only
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
See full details

2

Information

Cash-only neighborhood saloon with great burgers & classic vibe

Placeholder
Placeholder

5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
payment cash only
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
Red Key Tavern by null
See full details

More Places For You

St. Elmo Steak House

Steak house · Wholesale District

Historic steakhouse known for its fiery shrimp cocktail

7 Postcards

Apocalypse Burger

Hamburger restaurant · Mozel Sander Projects

Smashed burgers, crispy fries, unique onion rings, and decadent ding dongs

2 Postcards

Indianapolis City Market

Market · Mass. Ave Arts District

Historic food hall w/ diverse vendors, craft beer & tours

0 Postcards

Safeway

Supermarket · Downtown

Hot deli with fried chicken, pork chops, and sides

4 Postcards

The Workingman's Friend

Bar & grill · Mount Jackson

Iconic diner serves giant smash burgers & beer in chalices

3 Postcards

Mori Sushi

Japanese restaurant · Indianapolis

Sushi, ramen, signature rolls, and hibachi with free parking

1 Postcard

Manee Thai Cuisine Indy

Thai restaurant · Greenbriar

Thai specialties, vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free options, amazing taste

1 Postcard

Smash'd Midwest Burgers Irvington

Hamburger restaurant · Irvington

Classic smashburgers, loaded waffle fries, friendly staff

1 Postcard

Ruth's Chris Steak House

Restaurant · Keystone At the Crossing

Sizzling steaks, signature sides, and fine wines in an elegant setting

2 Postcards

Bluebeard

Fine dining restaurant · Fletcher Place

New American kitchen serving sharing plates & craft cocktails

7 Postcards