"Founded in Cincinnati In 1870, Graeter’s currently has scoop shops throughout the Midwest and also ships nationwide. You can create your own six-pint pack or go with a preselected flavor collection. AFAR’s executive editor Jeremy Saum says you can’t go wrong with any flavor with chocolate chips. 'Our family likes the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Mint Chocolate Chip, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, and just regular Chocolate Chip,' Saum says. 'Because they’re not ‘chips.’ They’re chunks. Or hunks.'" - Lyndsey Matthews