The 12 Best Hotels in Key West

"Steps from Mallory Square, a block from Duval Street, and fronting the cruise ship pier, Opal Key calls to those looking for the thick of Key West’s touristy action (with water views to boot). Prior to its incorporation into the growing Opal Collection in 2021, the property flew under various brand flags through decades past, including Hilton, Westin, and then Margaritaville. Across two buildings, there are a total of 178 rooms and suites dressed in coastal motifs with soft colors and wood furnishings. Overall, the interiors could use some zhuzhing, but the location is tops for Key West’s party vibe and the amenities are well done (These include a highly social pool scene, a state-of-the-art gym, and a Sunset Deck with views of the nightly sunset celebration on the pier.)" - Paul Rubio, Nancy DePalma