
5

"Laid-back with a surf shack vibe on the Napeague stretch right before you drive in or out of Montauk, this spot prides itself on the freshest local ingredients—the only store-bought items are the ketchup, mustard, and potato buns. Elevated tiki classics range from lobster fried rice and a crispy calamari salad to a sweet frozen Snickers dessert, with the crispy fish sammie and mussels among the top contenders." - Jessica Chapel