"The name may be Big Spoon, but these peanut butters are made in small batches in Hillsborough, North Carolina. Founders Mark and Megan Overbay only use the best ingredients, and you can taste the difference. The new El Rico chocolate peanut butter is a collaboration with California-based Rancho Gordo — it’s lovely on toast topped with bananas in the morning or straight out of the jar." - Erin Perkins