"With its waterfront setting that also plays home to Humphreys Concerts By the Bay, the dining and concert packages at this Shelter Island staple can make for a fun date night. Chef Jason Gethin’s modern SoCAL menu spans breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a popular Champagne brunch on weekends. There’s a solid cocktail list here too that favors rum-based and island-inspired creations." - Keri Bridgwater